Victim Of The Joke? An Opera

Rate It! Avg: 3.5 (19 ratings)

We’re sorry. This album is unavailable for download in your country (United States) at this time.

Victim Of The Joke? An Opera album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 16   Total Length: 50:49

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Barry Walters

eMusic Contributor

04.22.11
David Porter, Victim Of The Joke? An Opera
2001 | Label: Fantasy / Stax

Before he provided the voice of Chef on South Park, Isaac Hayes co-wrote R&B classics like Sam & Dave's "Soul Man" and "Hold On! I'm Coming" with a fellow Memphis, Tennessee, collaborator whose name is buried deeply in music history books, if at all: David Porter. While Hayes became the Shaft-celebrating Black Moses of '70s soul, Porter attempted a similarly orchestrated solo career by mixing down-home funk (here provided by the Bar-Kays and the Memphis Horns) with astoundingly elaborate symphonics.

Porter's 1971 album, Victim of the Joke?: An Opera, overlays even more drama in the form of extended spoken interludes chronicling the delirious private ups and catastrophic public downs of an archetypal love triangle. Although voice-acted with period blaxploitation excess, most of the talky segments pale next to Porter's musical grandiloquence. Like Hayes, Porter transforms pop hits like the Beatles '"Help!" into widescreen soul extravaganzas boasting jagged rhythm guitars, biting trumpet blasts and cooing female background singers. Porter's own opening and closing compositions provide much up-tempo momentum, but it's his labyrinthine treatment of the Tin Pan Alley oldie "The Masquerade Is Over" that should've made Porter a star. Over the course of nearly ten gloriously theatrical minutes, Porter constructs a roller… read more »

Write a Review 5 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

What the Hell??

isay

Why can't we get this in the US??

user avatar

Don't ignore

sebster

Unique, brilliant and preposterous. Pretty Inside made my day.

user avatar

The joke is on us

Jacked Up Jazz

This music holds up well over time and it sounds perfect for the time in which it was released. I really don't understand why David Porter didn't break on through to the other side. The neglect of David Porter as an artist is nothing less than a travesty of his talent and a tremendous hole in the soul of music. While we cannot bring back the glory days of Stax, we can start making amends by listing his name first in reviews of his work instead of his better known former writing partner.

user avatar

Victim of the Joke?

judehatch

This my 3rd purchase of this particular ALBUM!! I love it that much. The Ike Hayes influence is obvious on this one. Reminds me of my college days in NC. The scenario: I was dating 2 guys at once...which one would I sing the "Masquerade Song" to?

user avatar

Yo ho ho and a bottle of... fun!

straintest

This album is a classic. He was Isaac Hayes' writing partner.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

1

Stax In The 70s

By Dan Epstein, eMusic Contributor

In the four decades since Otis Redding's plane went down in a frozen Wisconsin lake on December 10, 1967, the notion that Stax Records (and its Volt subsidiary) died with him has become more or less accepted as gospel. This, however, couldn't be further from the truth; for while Redding's tragic death certainly represented the end of an era for Motown's biggest soul competitor, Stax continued to be a major musical and cultural force well… more »

They Say All Music Guide

Victim of the Joke?: An Opera is a concept album of sorts, the songs linked together by dialogue based around a thin romantic plot. The tunes (including both originals and surprising covers of the Beatles’ “Help!” and the Tin Pan Alley tune “The Masquerade Is Over”) are OK, but not special, treading closer to pop-soul than the grittier tone of many of David Porter’s ’60s compositions with Isaac Hayes. Porter’s voice, again, is OK but unremarkable. While the construction of the LP was a laudably ambitious outing by early-’70s soul standards, the results weren’t all that interesting; indeed, the thematic “concept” (of a typically rocky love affair) that drives the album is pretty simple and innocuous. – Richie Unterberger

more »