J.S. Bach: The Goldberg Variations

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (14 ratings)
J.S. Bach: The Goldberg Variations album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 32   Total Length: 54:04

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Thomas Bartlett

eMusic Contributor

04.22.11
Leonhardt's first recording of the Variations, from 1953, is definitive.
2004 | Label: IndieBlu Music / Entertainment One Distribution

Of the hundreds of available recordings of the Goldberg Variations, only a few are essential; this 1953 performance, famed Bach interpreter Gustav Leonhardt's first recording of the Variations, is one of them. Leonhardt was, along with Nikolas Harnoncourt, one of the most important figures in establishing the period instrument movement, advocating the use of historically accurate harpsichords and organs in the performance of Baroque music and mentoring a number of the scene's leading lights, including Christopher Hogwood and Ton Koopman. But his playing had little of the dry, motoric, mathematically exact style often associated with the movement. Indeed, he even performed Bach with a good deal of rubato — a rubato not inspired by a desire to squeeze some lyricism out of that least lyrical of all instruments, the harpsichord, as his predecessor Wanda Landowska had done, but instead used to ensure that every note of Bach's music was heard distinctly, was given the full attention that it deserved. That determination to make every note heard, along with Leonhardt's unusually and refreshingly spare use of ornamentation, results in a wonderfully lucid reading of the Goldberg Variations, played with unceasing focus, simplicity and grandeur.

Write a Review 4 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

For musicologists only

JoopKlinkhamer

I doubt whether Leonhardt himself would have been happy with this reissue. As neurotom points out, the 1978 interpretation is finer to the point of hardly ever been surpassed for its trandescent elements. I hope that it is going to be found at this site. But it is probably either teldec or deutsche harmonia mundi so this will not be very likely. It might be nice to compare his rendering to Christine Schornsheim'to be found on this website.

user avatar

Fine but not his best

Neurotom

Leonhardt later 1978 rendering is finer both in sound quality and interpretation, but hinledinkledoo rightly praises the 1953 sound quality, given its age. I would have thought, however, that the original tapes would have been the likely source of the transfer, not the 1953 version of Thomas Edison's work. The Nagra and Ampex recorders of the time were very good, perhaps only limted by the microphone quality.

user avatar

definitely or not

gemi-b

well, does 'a first' of a recording makes it definitive? i do not think so and know by reading leonhardt's comment that he is not lucky by this re-incarnation of an cold and poor sounding instrument/technique. as years went by leonhardt thought the goldbergs over and over to its audible result in 1978, his third and last and so for him definitive recording.

user avatar

Surprising sound for so old a recording

hinkledinkledoo

The sound quality on this recording is quite good considering how ancient it is (1953). These MP3s don't magnify the flaws of the primitive technology of the day--as is usually the case. It's too bad the re-recording/mixing engineer's name isn't mentioned. He did a fantastic job transfering Thomas Edison's turn of the 20th century technology into the 21st century's de facto format. This is an excellent intro to the so-called period instrument "movement" whose luminaries Koopman, Hogwood and Pinnock helped to revitalize Baroque's popularity in the 80s, a popularity which continues to this day. The so-called "movement" has swept the field and we can hear Bach and his fellow composers(as closely as we can guess) as their contemporaries did.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Classical Music at the Movies

By Anastasia Tsioulcas, eMusic Contributor

Ask any movie buff: music can be just as essential to a good film as its acting, plot line or cinematography. From the glory days of scores written by such legendary composers as Bernard Herrmann, Miklos Rosza and Elmer Bernstein to more recent and sublime scores by Ennio Morricone, John Williams and Danny Elfman, the music that propels action or colors a scene's mood can become a classic in its own right. In many instances, however,… more »

0

Classical Essentials

By Anastasia Tsioulcas, eMusic Contributor

What is that makes a classical recording something that you simply must own? We're not just talking about a tune that you hear on the radio or in the concert hall that you come away humming and slips your mind a short time later, or even an album that you feel you "should" have, but somehow never get around to actually hearing. Instead, we're talking here about melodies that invade your mind and don't let go.… more »