Tiny Cities

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (515 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION

Total Tracks: 11   Total Length: 30:29

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
J. Edward Keyes

Editor-in-Chief

04.22.11
A Red House Painter tackles the Modest Mouse songbook.
2005 | Label: Caldo Verde / Redeye

When he started recording as Red House Painters in the early '90s, Mark Kozelek's chief strength was his ability to make blunt emotional declarations sound poetic and mysterious by submerging them beneath churning, milky guitars. But Kozelek started running on fumes fast, relying on mealy singer-songwriter concoctions that fell far short of the drawn-out codeine coma of his early work. But then he stumbled on a new role: that of interpreter. His 2001 record of AC/DC covers found him burrowing past the machismo to find a genuinely wounded core cowering behind the bravado. His take on the band's snide and sexist "You Ain't Got A Hold on Me" cannily subverts the song's central tenet, making it sound less like a kiss-off and more like a desperate attempt by the singer to convince himself of the sentiment.

He takes a similar tack on this collection of Modest Mouse songs, with wildly varying results. Because the Seattle outfit isn't as aesthetically distant as Bon and the boys, there's less here for Kozelek to undo or uncover. As a result, the album feels like little more than a series of soporific covers, offering few new entryways into the material.

The songs that… read more »

Write a Review20 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Never a MM fan- but....

outoftheclosetmusicsnob

I agree with the reviewer that Mark treats these Modest Mouse songs as if they are his own- I adore this album- guitar work is sublime!!

user avatar

beautiful

gglah85

i heard this in a cd store and the lyrics sounded so familiar! then "Dramamine" began to play and i realized i was listening to Modest Mouse covers. i immediately bought the album and it's still as amazing now as it was the first time i heard it. one of my absolute favorite covers albums!

user avatar

Pretty and painful

Unsightly

I never knew the lyrics to alot of these Modest Mouse songs til Sun Kil Moon slowed them down... These are some of the best covers I've ever heard, Awesome album! Download this or I'll hit you on the face and punch you in the glasses.

user avatar

beautiful and haunting

theboldbrew

perfect album for a cold wintry day, Sun Kil Moon takes phenomenal songs and totally reinvents them in a way that gives them a totally different, almost elegant character. grab a book and pop this in.

user avatar

Same Lyrics, Different Emotions

TangerineLemming

"Tiny Cities" is a fascinating re-interpretation of 11 Modest Mouse songs. They're both ticked off about the same things, but he replaces MM's angry rants with hopeless resignation. It's intriguing to first listen to the originals and then notice how differently you feel after listening to SKM's interpretations. They're so different that I can no longer think of this as a covers album.

user avatar

888

kitty23

It's a different take on Modests mouse's moon and antarctica album W/ a couple songs on there from good news for people who love bad news.To everyone who are giving negative reviews you have to take into account that this is not modest mouse.It is a completley different artist and style interpreting modest's music.They are not goping to sound the same,however that doesnt mean it isnt good.Try to sit back and listen to his guitar and vocals and forget what the song should sound like and focus on what it does sound like now.It really is beautiful especially the guitar.

user avatar

Pretty, but not the best from Kozelek

polkatura

Mark Kozelek is probably the master of melancholy. His lulling, textured acoustic guitar and his soft, sad voice can reach right into my chest and tug on my heart just enough to make me see the world a little differently. I think this is the spell he has over me. This album is a collection of Modest Mouse covers. Kozelek is known amongst those who know him for recording an entire album of AC/DC covers, misery-style, rendering them completely unrecognisable. Modest Mouse get the same treatment, although I believe there is a certain upbeat quality to a lot of these songs that isn't typical from Kozelek. I don’t think this set of covers are as stunning as the AC/DC ones were; maybe this trick is getting a little worn out, but there’s still some worth and a lot of beauty here.

user avatar

Intrinsically gorgeous

gestalt-coolness

Call me insane, call me sheltered, call me lame, call me out of the freaking loop, but I honestly have never really listened to alot of Modest Mouse. I'm definitely aware that these songs sound absolutely nothing like the originals, but honestly, after listening to this album a million times, I simply cannot imagine these songs sounding another way. It's simply and undoubtedly just a beautiful album, proudly standing by itself. Absolutely worth downloading ALL. (Now that doesn't mean I won't ever delve more into Modest Mouse).

user avatar

Hmm...

Crisp

I think it's great for some chill back and relax outside kind of music. The guitar work and melodic tunes just kind of give you a little bounce inside-gorgeous work.

user avatar

he puts syrup in the words

Foxymophandlemama

very disappointing. the enthusiasm, spunk, fun, and emotion is sucked out of the original versions of these songs, and douched with what sounds like an Aunt Jemima microphone filter. first i fell asleep, then i deleted it off my hard drive. yuck.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

The curious sophomore effort from Mark Kozelek’s Sun Kil Moon — with both Geoff Stanfield and Anthony Koutsos returning from Ghosts of the Great Highway — is a tribute album to indie rockers Modest Mouse and is entirely made up of songs from their catalogue. That said, Kozelek treats these tunes as if he wrote them himself. The same blend of acoustic and electric guitars exist here as they did on the band’s debut, but Kozelek’s voice is mixed way up in an otherwise sparse production. Shimmering acoustic rock and country meld and wind together on “Neverending Math Equation,” and “Space Travel Is Boring.” The slow, off-waltz time of “Jesus Christ Was an Only Child” is, in a way, the hinge piece of a recording that deals with memory, childhood, and the emerging of a fragmented person built from these experiences. The allegorical tone of the tune suggests affinity, difference, and the small ways in which what we were taught when we were young opens up spaces in us where we can encounter the world. “Four Fingered Fishermen” acknowledges this with its small strolling blend of acoustic guitars and Kozelek’s iteration of his witness of those different than himself. The beautiful and moving “Grey Ice Water,” done mariachi style with backing vocals from Michi Aceret and Emily Herron, is the full articulation of seeing people and the world as somehow interconnected, no matter how random the encounter with them. Tiny Cities is so aptly titled, a recording of motion, the passing of distances, and the sometimes too-close experience of intersection, connection, and disconnection that happens in both open and claustrophobic environments — check “Trucker’s Atlas” for the rootless awareness of caged-in restlessness no matter how wide the terrain is to run and move. How it comes off is a seemingly original work, which makes it more extraordinary considering that these aren’t his songs. This is a gorgeous recording, one that in a very intimate way opens up an entire universe of possibility for understanding, integration, and brokenness. A fitting tribute indeed. – Thom Jurek

more »