All Your Things Are Gone

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (57 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 10   Total Length: 37:48

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
J. Edward Keyes

Editor-in-Chief

04.22.11
Victory At Sea, All Your Things Are Gone
2006 | Label: Gern Blandsten / The Orchard

"Watcha gonna do with all your lonely letters?" asks Mona Elliott at the beginning of "No Reason to Stay". It's clear what Elliott intends to do with hers. Over the course of All Your Things Are Gone, the dark and riveting sixth record from Boston's Victory at Sea, she laments her busted heart and condemns her bitter enemies. Sounding something like the Decemberists in a serious funk, Victory at Sea gilds its melancholy sea shanties with elaborate, bewitching piano lines. The songs have a kind of grandeur and ruined majesty — like a castle covered in moss or a crumbling statue of David.

The whole thing works because, for all their dramatic flourishes, Victory at Sea never let drama turn into melodrama. Elliott's got a cutting sense of humor, capable of deflating pomp with a single turn-of-phrase. "I would've turned to drugs/ but I turned to love," she sneers in "Bored Otherwise" as the piano does a stern death march in shadows behind her. She proves just as adept at channeling the loneliness of others; "Cecille", with its wounded protagonist and thundering percussion, is a mirror of Joy Division's "She's Lost Control", and the ominous "The Party" tracks the slow, painful… read more »

Write a Review6 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Get this one

raindogs

A female singer with a voice that will drive a stake through your heart, gorgeous piano, and a thundering drum sound that would put Steve Albini to shame. Yeah, you need this.

user avatar

Stunning

Touchedbyanoodle

It's a beautiful record. Sadly, their final album as a band. Must have! The first and last tracks on the album are the best, imo.

user avatar

an absolute must listen

tania

One of the best albums I've ever heard, truly beautiful. P.S.: And I am not related to any bandmember. Wombat sounds like s/he were dumped by one though.

user avatar

fantastic!

Ju

I love this record! It grows on you in a big way.

user avatar

ignore the shill above

WombatShellax

cecille reminds me of johnette napolitano before her voice got really husky, but the rest of this CD is pedestrian in my opinion, possibly the reviewer above is in the band or related to a band member?

user avatar

Their best album yet!!!!!!!

Yablonsky

Is it too early to declare this the best album of 2006? Because I can't see anyone else topping it. Mona Elliott's vox are just unearthly, and the music is piano-driven and somber but still really upbeat and catchy. Do yourself a favor and check this out!

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

At five albums in nearly 12 years, Victory at Sea are not the most productive of bands. But rather like two other long-running mixed-gender indie groups, Antietam and Yo La Tengo, the Boston-based trio has survived a long period of personnel instability with a lineup that has remained stable for a number of years, and that newfound permanence has allowed singer/songwriter Mona Elliott to refine and perfect the sound she’s been building toward since her first singles. Drummer Dave Norton and electric piano master Mel Lederman (who completely makes up for the band’s lack of a bassist in ways that the Doors’ Ray Manzarek never quite managed) are perfectly attuned to Elliott’s style, a uniquely appealing blend of mid-’90s slowcore and tetchy, experimental noise pop. In particular, Norton comes into his own on this album, nearly overpowering the Patti Smith-like ballad “Cecille” with walloping drum rolls that at times threaten to drown out the other instruments but are nonetheless just right for the song’s emotional swings. Similarly, Lederman’s subtle accompaniment for the grief-stricken “The Letter” gives Elliott’s elegiac lyric the gravitas it requires. Although not really an easy listen, All Your Things Are Gone is Victory at Sea’s most immediate and direct work yet. – Stewart Mason

more »