I am sitting in a room

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (75 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Track: 1   Total Length: 45:23

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Douglas Wolk

eMusic Contributor

Douglas Wolk writes about pop music and comic books for Time, the New York Times, Rolling Stone, Wired and elsewhere. He's the author of Reading Comics: How Gra...more »

04.22.11
A simple concept achieves magical ends
1981 | Label: Lovely Music / IODA

The concept behind Alvin Lucier's most famous piece, one of the landmarks of contemporary compositional music, is so simple that he explains it in a few sentences at its beginning. It's so simple, in fact, that the explanation itself is the music. Lucier notes that he's going to play the recording of his explanation back into the room, and record that, and repeat the process until the resonant frequencies of the room have eradicated the sound of his voice. Finally, he adds that the point of the exercise is "to smooth out any irregularities my speech might have."

That's the theory, but the brilliance of I Am Sitting in a Room is that its practice is much more complicated than its theory, and more moving, because of the flaws that make technology and architecture and people what they are. Most recordings don't acknowledge that they're recordings — they pretend that they're simply what you would have heard if your ears had been in some unspecified place at the right time. This one puts the lie to that idea, and makes the disparity between its setting and its listeners 'very obvious, too.

Recording and playback gear has improved over time (Lucier's first version… read more »

Write a Review9 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

no longer "one credit" unfortunatley

godsdog

This is an artist that I'm unfamiliar with an in the old days might have taken a chance on. The "sample" is useless as far as I'm concerned, where's the meat of the music?

user avatar

beautiful!

gdavidgross

if you have ever been skeptical about "experimental" music, take a risk on this one track album and listen to the whole thing, it's plain magic right in front of your ears.

user avatar

A Wonder

EMUSIC-01D34E60

Lucier turns the dry laws of sound into a transcendent experience. A seminal exploration of the nature of sound made very human through the presence of the composer's voice.

user avatar

back in time

gluv

This brings back memories of doing a workshop with Alvin Lucier when I was composing electronic music and room installations in Nottingham at Trent Poly. His is the most elemental and gentle of musics, human and elegant. Listening to this again makes me want to dig up all those reel to reels, tape loops, all the low budget effects, that I recorded. Giles Denmark Mitchell

user avatar

Simple genius

aikicinema

Although this is probably not a recording most people would listen to repeatedly, I enjoyed it thoroughly as a listening experience and plan to share it. I was surprised to find myself smiling constantly. During the first ten minutes it was fun discern at what point Lucier's voice disappeared. But what pleased me most was when I thought that the recording could not get anymore resonant and melodious, I saw the track had twenty more minutes. And it continued to get even prettier. And it is only ONE download.

user avatar

Trippy

frethepig

Maybe it was the rum and coke, but I was really starting to trip on this thing about halfway through. Just amazing! It really resonates through the brain-box with headphones. For one download, you won't hear much like this anywhere else. These are the things that have kept me a loyal Emusic subscriber and fan!

user avatar

Much more enjoyable than it could have been...

richard.watson8

Hey, cool! Towards the end it sounds more like music than some other stuff I've listened to. It's exactly like feedback from your guitar except in a very slow motion.

user avatar

essential

kargatron

Simply put, one of the absolute essential pieces of 20c. experimental music. An amazing concept and an amazing first listen.

user avatar

reverb... shoegaze avant-garde

J'Adorno

Alvin Lucier's most famous (relatively, of course) piece finds him playing out a simple set up, as he explains in the piece: "I am sitting in a room different from the one you are in now. I am recording the sound of my speaking voice and I am going to play it back into the room again and again until the resonant frequencies of the room reinforce themselves, so that any semblance of my speech, with perhaps the except of rhythm, is destroyed. What you will hear then are the natural resonant frequencies of the room articulated by speech. I regard this activity not so much as a demonstration of a physical fact, but more as a way to smooth out any irregularity my speech might have." After about 25 minutes, his voice becomes pure sound and does indeed echo the room itself. Amazing experiment in ambiance that will appeal to both Eno and My Bloody Valentine fans. (the latter should play the track backwards).

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

“I am sitting in a room, different from the one you are in now.” So begins one of the masterpieces of 20th century music merging processed music, minimalism, and self-reference into an utterly amazing and ultimately beautiful work. The instructions for producing the piece are, in fact, the piece itself. The composer sits and describes what will happen, and then it happens. Lucier tapes these instructions (about 80 seconds worth), tapes it, replays that tape into the room, tapes that, plays the second tape into the room, etc., and so on. Little by little, the “natural resonant frequencies of the room” erode the source material, softening hard edges, blurring boundaries between words. Different rooms will, presumably, give different results depending on their individual architectural properties. After ten or 12 repetitions, the listener already has difficulty distinguishing individual words, though the rhythmic pattern remains. But, and this is one of the cruxes of the work, all is not entropy. As the text becomes indecipherable, elements of undeniably musical tones emerge from nowhere, as though they were embedded in the original speech and only came to light after the surface structure was eliminated. Indeed, small melodies can actually be heard and the effect is absolutely magical. Fifteen minutes into the composition, Lucier’s speech has become a hazy cloud of wavering, bell-like tones interrupted by the occasional sibilance, the latter generated by the composer’s stutter, which adds an element of poignancy to the piece’s conception. Halfway through, no aspect of the speech can be gleaned except a rough cadence; instead, the listener has been transported to a sound world at such a far remove from the initial text as to leave one both baffled and awash in wonder. I Am Sitting in a Room is a unique, extraordinary idea/composition, a landmark among late 20th century avant-garde music and a touchstone for a generation of composer/theoreticians. It’s a rare combination of sensual beauty and intellectual rigor, and should be heard by anyone interested in contemporary music. – Brian Olewnick

more »