Good
Although you can really see growth from this album to the next one 'You & Me'. Not sure why eMusic doesn't offer that one. I do like Louisiana from this collection though.
Although you can really see growth from this album to the next one 'You & Me'. Not sure why eMusic doesn't offer that one. I do like Louisiana from this collection though.
Definitely their thinnest album. The great Walkmen songs are still there, just not as many in number. The band has honed some of these tunes since this album was released, however; many of them sound great live.
The Walkmen's cover is brilliant in its own way, but the original by Mazarin IS WORTH SEEKING OUT. (from 'We're Already There', not on emusic however) Quentin from Mazarin is a Walkmen FRIEND, so to 'rooms' from S.F., the reference is probably mention of the cover and not a band sound comparison.
but on the songs that they do hit, they are out of the park. Seems like the epic songs on each album are four. For me, those are "All Hands and the Cook" (utterly haunting), "Good For You's Good For Me", "Lost in Boston", and "Louisiana". Always seems to be some filler with them, but their highs are so high. Can't wait for the new album!
This is their best album so far. All their albums have weak points, so focus on the good: Louisiana, Danny's At The Wedding, Good for You's Good For Me, All Hands And The Cook, Lost In Boston, This Job Is Killing Me, Brandy Alexander, and And Another One Goes By. Yum! Also, ignore the reference to Marizpan or whatever that band's name is that somebody plugged here. While they're fine classic 80's rock, they sound nothing like the Walkmen.
First song is by far their best song ever -- rest of the album is typically spotty with moments of brilliance.
What I like about The Walkmen is that their music has got a distinctive character -- the vocals are playfully morose and the sounds they get out of their instruments are really unique. I must have played the song "This Job is Killing Me" a million times on infinite repeat after I first heard it.
Back in '04, it was with mild amusement that I noticed The Walkmen's second album, Bows + Arrows. "Wow," I thought. "They're actually trying this thing again, eh?" And sure enough, Bows + Arrows was more of the same, a pleasant, if played-out rehash of their stellar debut Everyone Who Pretended to Like Me is Gone. Now, the band I could barely imagine releasing a second album has hit number three, and it's actually pretty amazing. The first track "Louisiana" shows off a bright horn section, ushering us into a new era of The Walkmen. Not all these songs work ("Emma, Get Me a Lemon" in particular grates), but they prove that The Walkmen are not content to stagnate musically. Not sure where they'll go from here, but it should be interesting.
mazarin didn't break up--rejoice! just a name change...tbd
If you like the free track check out the original by the band Mazarin (who recently broke up, sadly): myspace.com/mazarinband. They're awesome too.