Who's On First

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (87 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 5   Total Length: 27:26

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Michael Azerrad

eMusic Contributor

eMusic editor-in-chief Michael Azerrad is the author of Come As You Are: The Story of Nirvana (Doubleday, 1993), which remains the definitive Nirvana biography,...more »

04.22.11
An iconic comedy routine.
2007 | Label: Stardust / The Orchard

It's hard to think of a more iconic comedy routine than Abbott & Costello's "Who's on First." Indeed, in 1999, Time magazine named it "The Best Comedy Sketch of the 20th Century." Take that, Cheech & Chong! "Who's on first?" has become a catch-phrase for any confusing situation, and linguists have used the exchange as an example of all sorts of concepts, like "dialogue act disambiguation" and "use-mention indicators." It's so deeply ingrained in our cultural consciousness that it's easy to take for granted, or perhaps not even bother actually listening to. But download this classic — it's still really funny, a marvel of timing, teamwork and wordplay.

The origins of the piece are actually really controversial, with several credible versions of the story, but suffice it to say, similar bits had been kicking around the burlesque circuit for ages, and Abbott & Costello debuted theirs on Kate Smith's popular radio show in 1938, picking up on baseball's longstanding tradition of nicknames, like "Pepper," "Preacher" and "Flash," and coming up with maddening monikers like "Who," "What" and "I Don't Know." The show's producers allegedly didn't think the bit would translate to an audio-only medium, but it was an instant hit; for… read more »

Write a Review9 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

A Cultural Touchstone

Dad

It's a piece of history. You have to have it.

user avatar

for my dad

naidre

i downloaded this as a gift for my dad. couldn't have been a better gift. do it.

user avatar

Classic Comedy

Eclectic_Taste

I first heard the Who's On First routine as a kid, and still love it today. Even better, I can share this kind of comedy with my nephews and not worry that they'll go home with a new vocabulary - one that their parents won't approve of.

user avatar

Got to have it

coopco95843

Hey - where else are you going to get a classic like this for 33 cents!

user avatar

True Classic

KyleM

The title track is just amazing -- two masters of comedy in their prime. It's a track I can listen to regularly, and it never gets old. The rest of the tracks give a great sense of what the entire live radio show sounded like at the time, including Lucille Ball as a guest --- who can certainly hold her own!

user avatar

Joey

Thok

This has to be the best comedy skit I have ever heard, even at 18 years old, I believe this was the golden age of Comedy.

user avatar

Timeless Classic Comedy

BigDudeUK

Brilliant piece of comedy that never fails to make me laugh, even though I am from the UK so don't follow baseball...

user avatar

Relive the past

VMMDJ

What a great chance to listen to some timeless comedy. The last track does not have much to it, but it still is fun to listen to.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

An eMusic Guide To Comedy

By eMusic Editorial Staff

What makes something funny? People will tell you it's timing. That's not the whole truth. Sure, the right moment, a confluence of mishaps and commentary can result in hilarity. But personality is at a premium in comedy. The person behind the timing is as vital as any open manhole or stray banana peel. Luckily, at eMusic, we've got personality by the bundle. Below you'll find a curated collection of some of the funniest folks to… more »