eMusic Review
The Choir Practice may consist of indie rock illuminati, but its sound is that of Peter, Paul & Mary or the Serendipity Singers. “Well-scrubbed” is the word that AllMusic uses to describe the latter and it works for the Choir Practice too. The songs sung by Coco Culbertson (former bassist of the Gay), Kurt Dahle (New Pornographers) and a whole host of others have been scoured within an inch of their lives. “I See Things” seems to merely feature a four-note bassline, a piano, a tambourine and about 15 voices. It's perhaps the most overstuffed track, instrument-wise, aside from the brilliant “Red Fox,” which is the clear standout of the disc. “Fox” seemingly abandons the AM Gold sheen of much of the work here, allowing the group's singers to swerve to excitingly out-of-tune places, only to be brought back to their senses moments later. It's a relative anomaly on The Choir Practice, but that shouldn't keep you from sampling the rest. Just because the Choir Practice tend to keep it together more often than not doesn't mean there aren't dirty secrets and dusky gems to be uncovered. Remember how innocent “Puff the Magic Dragon” sounded at first?