Monk

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (70 ratings)
Monk album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 12   Total Length: 58:52

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Charles Farrell

eMusic Contributor

Since returning to active playing in 2005 after a career as a boxing manager, pianist Charles Farrell has released eleven CDs, played with Ornette Coleman, and ...more »

12.29.08
A jazz giant brings Monk to the guitar
2009 | Label: Xanadu Records / The Orchard

If ever there was a jazz composer whose work wouldn't seem guitar-friendly, it is Thelonious Monk. Piano players can tap into the basic percussiveness of his pieces and horn players can dig aggressively into his blowing tunes or rhapsodize over the ballads. But a guitarist, especially one whose style owes much to the traditional masters like Jim Hall and Joe Pass, might seem too timid.

Peter Bernstein has figured out a way to take on Monk without sacrificing any of the guitar's natural attributes. He knows Monk's material backward and forward, but eschews the music's quirkiness in favor of its architecture. The key here is using musical intelligence. In this pursuit, he is ably assisted by bass player Doug Weiss and the understandably ubiquitous drummer Bill Stewart. By collectively reducing the flamboyant elements of Monk's music, they get to the spare beauty found beneath the surface.

There's a calm to the opening “Let's Cool One” that allows Bernstein to slowly build his solo, a blend of articulate single note runs and strategically based chordal references. Weiss's solo follows, and then Bernstein trades fours with Stewart. The drummer is able to play with great force at minimal volume. The exquisite ballad “Pannonica” is… read more »

Write a Review 9 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Well You Need To...

EMUSIC-0030F15D

...check out Peter Bernstein's superbly well thought out take on Thelonious Monk. Harmonically adventurous and superbly crafted arrangements. Bernstein captures the spirit of Monk on the guitar in a way that few have!

user avatar

It's a bop guitar trio...

MarkSullivan

Bernstein is a guitarist in the bebop tradition, and this is a guitar/bass/drums trio, which sounds somewhat laid-back by definition. He doesn't minimize the dissonance in the heads, but he doesn't throw gratuitous dissonance into his solos, either--it's not his style. Johnny Griffin didn't do that with Monk, and he's one of my favorite Monk sidemen. If Kenny Burrell recorded a Monk album, it would sound a lot like this.

user avatar

Better than I expected.

joeyallred

A very relaxed enjoyable set.

user avatar

Its Monks Time, Its Bernstein, How Cn U Go Wrong!

djdaf

I'm sorry, but dooflow you are out of line. "Aural Wallpaper Drivel" can be applied to a ton of "musicians" here in 2009, but NOT Bernstein. It's not every guitar player who can be Joe Morris or R.I.P. Sonny Sharrock, nor would they want to be. Any recording that covers exclusively Monk is on the right track. I will admit there are plenty of smooth moments at least in the samples (I'm out of DL till my month refreshes). IMHO Bernstein's best work is with organists Larry Goldings and Dr. Lonnie Smith, so I'm disappointed this Monk project doesn't have that type of lineup ("Bemsha Swing" is a staple of Dr. Lonnie's sets, whoever the guitarist might be). I'm glad Bernstein is getting some wider recognition with the Blue Note 7, but that's another discussion.

user avatar

Much needed take on Monk

EMUSIC-00A3B205

Peter Bernstein fills a void in jazz guitar recordings. A whole album of Monk is a daring proposition for a guitarist. Peter pulls it off brillantly. Check out Well You Needn't in 5/4. Mark McCarron

user avatar

Scholl, Maybe He Bought a CD

frankiepop

Before you trash another's review. Think. Maybe he borrowed a cd or heard it on the radio. I don't think you have to download an album here to review it. I heard the cd from a co-worker, and I have to say dooflow's review was right on target to my sentiments. A few tracks worked like "In Walked Bud" and "Brilliant Corners." In its entirety I think what doo is saying is that Bernstein managed to turn the most interesting composer of the last century into a bore.

user avatar

Dooflow ... did you fileshare?

Scholl

Kind of an odd perspective you have about the album, since it doesn't even show up in your downloaded music profile. Anyway, I liked it.

user avatar

Thelonious G.

dooflow

Anything that "eschews the music’s quirkiness in favor of its architecture" (read: smooths out the rough edges aka personality & texture) is not Monk. Get Braxton's or Lacy's versions of Monk rather than this aural wallpaper drivel.

user avatar

Great Feel For Monk!

Dhfalcon23

Peter Bernstein has a great feel for Monk. Which is pretty cool since most jazzmen who play Monk are piano or horn players, as noted in the e-music review. It doesn't hurt that he's got a great personnel with him (especially Bill Stewart on drums!!) Worth downloading for sure!

Recommended Albums

They Say All Music Guide

Monk, Peter Bernstein’s seventh album, is also his first in four and a half years, following Stranger in Paradise, which was released in Japan. It’s being issued by the newly reactivated Xanadu label, which has come back into existence mainly to reissue previous albums, and this one, although a current recording, also has the air of a retrospective. As its title suggests, it’s a tribute to Thelonious Monk, employing all Monk compositions. The tribute album is a typical strategy to boost sales in jazz, of course, but the twist here is that Bernstein is a guitarist while Monk was a pianist, and in this case the only additional musicians are bassist Doug Weiss and drummer Bill Stewart. A pianoless trio playing Monk tunes obviously requires some adjustments, and in some cases Bernstein has effected approximations of Monk’s themes rather than strict transpositions. Some notes may be harder to get to quickly enough on the guitar, and then the notes decay faster, as well. One curious effect of the changed instrumentation is that Monk’s music actually sounds less unusual on the guitar than it does on the piano. Even when, as on “Work,” Bernstein takes off into some odd soloing, somehow the guitar makes the music sound more conventional. Bernstein is at his most impressive when he only uses Monk for a template and, especially, when he dispenses with the rhythm section, as he does on “Monk’s Mood” and “Ruby, My Dear,” not to mention on “Reflections,” in which, through the magic of overdubbing, he accompanies himself. – William Ruhlmann

more »