Good
Good album with obvious influences from Pink Floyd and King Crimson. Afret a few listens I started to enjoy it.
Good album with obvious influences from Pink Floyd and King Crimson. Afret a few listens I started to enjoy it.
Yes, I'm a prog fan, Yes, I'd read reviews by some praising this as an album of the year candidate. My opinion is some great playing does not compensate for muffled vocals and dingy production. Good yes, great, not to my ears. I'll be listening to see what they come up with next time. As for "The Wierding", I don't think I'll return for a second listen anytime soon.
WHY ?! Why go back and re-create 1970? I like a lot of bands that were creative in 1970, Amon Duul, Floyd, Yes, etc. but not this wanky attempt to re-create it. Just plain boring...
This is a great guilty pleasure for us crazy proggies, that's for sure. But it really represents only that tiny "glimpse of nirvana" that we got at the turn of the '70s from Pink Floyd's "Saucerful" to "Meddle" and King Crimson's "Court" to "Lizard" and just an occasional glimpse after that such as Steve Hackett's "Acolyte". Thank you, Astra, and God bless us proggies, we need it !!!!!!! (PS to GTMLIBRA, the cardboard box is no doubt due to the MP3 compression. We should all go out and buy the real album, preferably remixed by Steve Wilson for SACD surround sound.)
Good retro sounding prog, but why record it in a box?! Bands like Camel and Caravan have remastered their backlog catalog and they sound great, so why make a new album in a card board box? If you want retro, buy a Litmus or Brighteye Bison album. ALL the albums I have downloaded from emusic sound fantastic on my Cowon J3. Sadly this album really does have very poor production which is a pity because a lot of us like Retro sounding albums.
If you are a fan of the sound and feel of classic '70s prog this is an album to check out. These guys have clearly done their homework and, like a lot of bands, they reference the music they love in their own work. That's not a bad thing but it can mean that the listener ends up spotting influences rather than concentrating on Astra's work. If you lament the way that the classic prog bands tried to turn into pop groups in the '80s Astra could be the band to restore your faith in complexity, length and mellotrons. Great stuff.
This could go right in with all of the other prog/psych discs I bought during the initial run of progressive. Crimson is plugged, and Floyd stolen...but that is music.
CANTBELIEVEIMPAYINGFORTHISCRAP
A decent-enough throwback, but Ouroboros is too long, and Beyond the Slight to the Maze is too repetitive. The overwrought touches are par for the course in 70s style art-rock, I suppose.
Good but not great retro prog. You would think you're listening to something recorded around 1971 drums sound a little flat but pretty good retro prog with nice guitar and mellotron.
QUITE POSSIBLY 'THE ROCK ALBUM' OF THE YEAR