Easy Star's Lonely Hearts Dub Band

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (450 ratings)
Easy Star's Lonely Hearts Dub Band album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 15   Total Length: 57:13

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Michelangelo Matos

eMusic Contributor

04.14.09
Everyone's favorite stoner-rock reggae reinterpreters give Sgt. Pepper a rasta makeover
2009 | Label: Easy Star Records / IODA

It's official: the Easy Star All Stars have an ironclad formula. Every three years, the Brooklyn dub-reggae troupe gathers a giant list of guest vocalists and covers a classic-rock album beloved by teenage stoners. (We'll probably have to wait a while for them to get to any post-Kyuss "stoner rock," though I'd certainly like to hear what they'd do with Queens of the Stone Age's Rated R.) Following the surprising success of 2003's Dub Side of the Moon (rasta Floyd!) and 2006's Radiodread (OK Computer inna rub-a-dub style!), Easy Star's Lonely Hearts Dub Band arrives right on schedule.

Like the others, it's a mixed success. The vocalist roster is heavy on Jamaican legends like Frankie Paul ("Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" adapts very nicely to the All Stars 'pumping mid-tempo skank) and Sugar Minott, whose slight crags give "When I'm Sixty-Four" some depth, particularly during the bridge ("We could rent a cottage in the Isle of Wight, if it's not too dear/We shall scrimp and save"). (The track's continuing on into an extended dub is conceptually appropriate, too.) Then there's, um, Matisyahu, who is naturally assigned the dullest song on the original album. (You only thought… read more »

Write a Review 38 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Fun For A Few Plays

Palomino-Royalle

The idea is good, and it's well executed, but... I just don't find myself coming back to this one very often. I don't hate it. Don't love it, either. Oh well.

user avatar

Lovely Rita and Bob and Peter...

velocipede

Sgt. Pepper's was the first album I was given when I got a turntable for Christmas. I listened to it many many times, which is probably why it eventually became one of my least favorite Beatles albums (blasphemy!). Thanks to the Easy Star All-Stars, I have recovered. Listening to this a few times, loosened up my ears and heart to re-appreciate the Fab Four Masterpiece again. That's not saying this is not staying in heavy rotation too! (And, yeah, beats the pants off Cheap Trick's live version too.)

user avatar

I liked Dub Side of the Moon better

Grifyn

but this is still great fun. I wonder what they'll do next...

user avatar

An enjoyable listen, but not a revolution.

DrBlackBerry

Dub Side of The Moon was a transformative album for me. It took an already recognized classic, and did it justice by duplicating a lot of the original sounds and effects while adding dub dimensions entirely fitting to the mood Pink Floyd intended, whilst infusing the Rasta culture into the English. In the same vein, Radiodread pulled a similar blend out of the studio on what was another complex, moody album. Perhaps the Easy Stars were just tempted by the rhyming of "Club" and "Dub", but while well executed, Lonely Heart's Dub Band is pulling from a pop classic with neither the depth nor complexity of Dub Side of The Moon or OK Computer. The album is certainly enjoyable to listen to, it just doesn't provide the same soul-searching transcendence of either or their previous efforts.

user avatar

Disappointing, Not a Single Good Song

djkittycat

They could have done so much more with this, and they didn't. Every song they did they did in the same exact style, instead of getting creative and diverse like they did with the first two albums. Guess they thought they could release any old thing to a generic reggae beat and people would lap it up. I mean they even made the more interesting and psychedelic songs on the original album sound like crap. That takes some serious awful.

user avatar

Tasty

teapot1

I really like this and so do a number of people I've "lent it to". My favourite of the 3 - but then I'm not a darkside of the moon or radiohead fan.

user avatar

Mmmmmm !!!

admiralbenbow

I love Dub Side Of The Moon. Fantastic album. So I was really looking forward to this. Unfortunately, this album is nowhere near as good. Really disappointing. Just buy The Beatles original and stick with that.

user avatar

Too easy

Zigster

They've taken every easy listening option here. This is the music they play in Jamaican lifts and supermarkets.

user avatar

Fun one time!

AbelHand

I enjoyed this, as I enjoyed their last outing, but I'm also almost certain that, again like their last outing, I won't listen to it twice. This isn't music, really, it's just novelty. But the first time through it's interesting to hear the songs recast in a new light.

user avatar

Meh

djFLWB

As a reggae fan and Beatles fan and a collector of covers I was hoping for much better so I have to semi-agree with music4thesoul. It isn't all twaddle but it isn't as good as Dub Side which was much better than Radiodred. But there are still a few good tracks on here. Tracks 7,13&14 are worth downloading the balance is fairly run of the mill cover formula in a reggae dub style. If you don't have Dub Side of the Moon get that first. Then come back to this later.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

The Easy Star All-Stars Dubble Your Pleasure

By Richard Gehr, eMusic Contributor

"Versioning," the reuse of sturdy and sticky rhythmic material, is a reggae cornerstone. There's pleasure to be found in repetition, a notion that the Easy Star All-Stars have exploited with a certain conceptual genius since their 2003 release of Dub Side of the Moon, the New York-based collective's meticulously arranged and elegantly performed reggae version of Pink Floyd's ridiculously popular psychedelic masterpiece. The All-Stars followed up Dub Side's success in 2006 with Radiodread, an equally… more »

They Say All Music Guide

After their full coverage of classic albums from both Radiohead and Pink Floyd, the collective known as the Easy Star All-Stars go way back to the band and the album that pretty much changed everything. The accent, as always, is on the Easy part of the band’s name, meaning this easy-skanking tribute to Sgt. Pepper’s flows effortlessly, never getting caught up in overly ambitious detours or ridiculously huge arrangements. Tracks like “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds” with guest vocalist Frankie Paul and “Within You Without You” with natural mystic Matisyahu have slick studio touches, but the heavy lifting is left up to the performances, and both guest vocalists are perfect choices who simply nail it. Having been on the road frequently the previous two years pays off, as the players are suitably loose, creating grooves that feel natural and alive. The ever growing importance of the horn section comes to fruition as they shrink some of the original album’s elaborate arrangements into smaller packages, ones that could be imagined in a live setting or — in the case of Ranking Roger’s “Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite” — at some wicked ska-fueled pool party. The warm voice of Michael Rose closes the set on a dubby “A Day in the Life,” a cover version drenched in reverb with a clever imitation of the locked groove gibberish found at the end of the original Pepper’s LP. – David Jeffries

more »