A Society In Which No Tear Is Shed is Inconceivably Mediocre…

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (89 ratings)
A Society In Which No Tear Is Shed is Inconceivably Mediocre… album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 14   Total Length: 40:45

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Richard Gehr

eMusic Contributor

Richard Gehr has been writing about international music -- and many other things -- for more than two decades. After moving to Los Angeles from Portland, OR, vi...more »

04.13.09
Emotionally fragile, cerebrally sophisticated demos from a promising talent cut tragically short
Label: Luaka Bop

"I know what it's like to be left out when all your friends try the new hip suicide thing," sang young Brazilian songwriter Yonlu — AKA Vinicius Gageiro Marques — in what became the first track of a remarkable posthumous debut assembled from music the 16-year-old left behind after himself committing suicide in 2006. ("Yonlu" was the screen name Marques used on the songwriters'bulletin board where he posted several of these tracks). Some of the songs on this surprisingly uplifting collection — notably "I Know What It's Like," "Luana (Mêcanica Celeste Aplicada)," and "Waterfall" — stand up with the best Brazilian popular music on record. Others are obviously the work of a young experimentalist who had yet to find his voice and, in a very real sense, died trying.

Several tunes on A Society in Which No Tear Is Shed… address suicide directly, though usually with a deceptive, self-mocking wink. "I'll tell you why I wanna die," Yonlu sings of his latest romantic failure in "Humiliations"; he cries wolf again in the strangely literal "Suicide," which concludes, "Now my suicide is lit by the sunset/ It's pretty sad if you ask me." Indeed. As artistically precocious as he was emotionally fragile,… read more »

Write a Review 3 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Sad story. Wonderful music.

hhjack

It's a shame that a kid with this much talent had to leave us so young. I can only imagine what he would have been able to accomplish.

user avatar

Amazing and heart breaking

jdhatl

This is in the top 5 of the year so far, absolutely amazing. It is very depressing if you listen the whole way through, but this kid was a total musical genius. It will make you happy and sad at the same time. Thank you Luaka Bop for letting us all hear this amazing album

user avatar

AMAZING!

chanticlere

All my years of listening to the commercial artist trying to be lo-fi rock stars! Yet, all that time was wasted when there was something as pure and honest as this! I'm now convinced that it takes a special person to produce lo-fi heart felt honest music. And Yonlu is the only artist 110% capable. I wish there was more!

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

The Secret Society of Yonlu

By Richard Gehr, eMusic Contributor

"Quick, someone say something really nice about my songs before I decide to KILL MYSELF," wrote Vinicius Gageiro Marques on the online gaming message board Rilmuk two months prior to killing himself on July 26, 2006. Marques, who operated under the screen name Yoñlu, had posted some two dozen rough-yet-compelling low-fi bedroom productions to the forum. Despite his pleas, Vinicius/Yoñlu didn't seem to lack for approval. The community regularly applauded his strong melodies, frail vocals,… more »

They Say All Music Guide

Until 2009, the music of Yonlu lived only in the virtual world on MySpace and on Luaka Bop’s Three Inches of Music series. Yonlu was born Vinicius Gageiro Marques, and he hailed from Porto Alegre, Brazil. The difficult part of the story is that Yonlu was a very serious and sensitive young man who found life in this realm unbearable. He took his own life via carbon monoxide poisoning while signed on to a suicide forum on the internet, and remained online to the end, just 36 days before his 17th birthday, and after writing a long letter absolving his parents of any responsibility whatsoever. He left his parents a CD of his music before he died, but it was later, while going through his computer, that his father found most of the songs on A Society in Which No Tear Is Shed Is Inconceivably Mediocre. To his astonishment, he also discovered that Yonlu’s music had made its way to many corners of the world and had been commented upon by various friends, DJs, and critics.
That’s the myth, sad though it may be. The 14 songs that make up this collection are something else, however. They’re infused with a freshness, innocence, and musical vision that is singular in scope and breadth. Yonlu’s inspirations were myriad: they ranged from Radiohead and Elliott Smith to Gilberto Gil and the entire Tropicalia movement to classic bossa nova. Indeed, if this music can be called anything at all, it is 21st century bossa, infused by lo-fi and post-rock aesthetics. Yonlu was a musical and cultural polymath (he was an accomplished visual artist) whose sensitivity was matched only by his ability to realize his creativity. Check the tape manipulation skullduggery in “A Boy and a Tiger,” where new acoustic, indie rock, samba, hip-hop, and spoken word all take their place in a mix that is dazzling in its reach yet utterly breezy in its space. “Humiliation” weaves together the tenderness of Caetano Veloso with the emotional pathos of Smith and Badly Drawn Boy. His cover of the Kings of Convenience’s “Little Kids” is brief, but draws equally on shimmering bossa rhythms, overdubbed acoustic guitars, what sounds like a harp, and a rather complex bassline. Likewise his reading of the great gaucho artist Vitor Ramil’s (another big influence on Yonlu) “Estrela Estrela,” which is done reverentially and tenderly, carrying within it all the honest, open emotion of the original and adding intricately woven acoustic and nylon-string guitars. But the true wealth of this material lies in Yonlu’s own songs. Of course it is tempting to read this through his tragic biography, but to do so would sell this music short. Check the primitive bossa meets futuristic MPB of “Ole Por Nos,” with its delicately layered vocals, the messed up folktronica of “Q-Tip,” or the glitchy edited loops on “Deskjet Remix with Sabrepulse,” directed by the sounds of a charango. The set closes with “Waterfall,” an utterly gorgeous and haunting folk song where layers upon layers of vocal harmony are chanted, sometimes in falsetto, sometimes in basso, and fall around an acoustic guitar treated with lacey reverb, sparse keyboards, and an atmosphere so thick its beauty is almost Baroque — and all this before the rhythm loops kick in. It is as celebratory, innocent, and unremittingly beautiful as anything you are likely to ever hear. This may be the only recording we ever get to hear from Yonlu, but as such, it is a treasure trove of complexity, mystery, and redemptive art. Indeed, this is bedsit music elevated to the realm of high art. – Thom Jurek

more »