eMusic Review 0
Cleaves 'previous album, 2006's Unsung, was a mixed blessing. It was a Slaid Cleaves album — which is never a bad thing. The trouble was, it wasn't an album of Slaid Cleaves songs. Instead, the Austin-based artist chose to tip his hat to some of his comrades toiling among the legions of criminally underrated sing-songwriters.
In a remotely sane or just world, Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away would see Cleaves finally escaping this peer group, and basking in the sort of mainstream regard accorded Ryan Adams or Steve Earle. It may count against Cleaves that he does several things brilliantly, as opposed to just one thing reliably, and "Everything You Love. . ." is a characteristically diverse tour-de-force: Cleaves can be funny (the Haggard-esque saloon-bar singalong "Tumbleweed Stew"), lachrymose (the Guy Clark-alike "Cry") and angry ("Beautiful Thing" is a savagely articulate protest song that evokes both the anger of John Prine and the sarcasm of Todd Snider).
As ever, it's necessary to make the effort to meet the chronically modest Cleaves at least halfway to his own terms: his songs disdain crass hooks, but his melodies are insidious and meticulously crafted — check the way… read more »