Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (193 ratings)
Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 11   Total Length: 41:12

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Andrew Mueller

eMusic Contributor

04.21.09
Cleaves continues to be the best alt-country singer/songwriter you're not listening to
2009 | Label: Music Road / IODA

Cleaves 'previous album, 2006's Unsung, was a mixed blessing. It was a Slaid Cleaves album — which is never a bad thing. The trouble was, it wasn't an album of Slaid Cleaves songs. Instead, the Austin-based artist chose to tip his hat to some of his comrades toiling among the legions of criminally underrated sing-songwriters.

In a remotely sane or just world, Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away would see Cleaves finally escaping this peer group, and basking in the sort of mainstream regard accorded Ryan Adams or Steve Earle. It may count against Cleaves that he does several things brilliantly, as opposed to just one thing reliably, and "Everything You Love. . ." is a characteristically diverse tour-de-force: Cleaves can be funny (the Haggard-esque saloon-bar singalong "Tumbleweed Stew"), lachrymose (the Guy Clark-alike "Cry") and angry ("Beautiful Thing" is a savagely articulate protest song that evokes both the anger of John Prine and the sarcasm of Todd Snider).

As ever, it's necessary to make the effort to meet the chronically modest Cleaves at least halfway to his own terms: his songs disdain crass hooks, but his melodies are insidious and meticulously crafted — check the way… read more »

Write a Review 12 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Yep, that's Slaid, all right.

chickenfoof

Slaid must have been smiling especially wryly as he decided on the title. It encapsulates everything that shuts down the broader fan base he ought to be enjoying, and yet he's a very good-humored guy. Thankfully, Gurf Morlix has thrown out the honky-tonk trappings that sunk 2004's Wishbones. Slaid sounds like Slaid here -- genuine and tough-but-gentle. And the album starts well and ends well. "Cry" will make you do just that. Things sag a bit in the middle, but there are moments toward the beginning and end, including "Hard to Believe," Green Mountains and Me," and "(It's a) Beautiful Thing." And "Temporary" gently brings us back to where we started, reminding us once more that everything we love will be taken away. Would that the whole album were as strong as its bookends, but it does sound like Slaid's staking out some new direction. Let's hope we don't have to wait another five years to see where he's headed.

user avatar

Alt-country? Folk noir? Great!

ookpik

Echoing other reviewers: Slaid Cleaves is dark but life-affirming, often sad but sometimes funny (or a combination!), intelligent lyrics and some of the best melodies around. "Everything You Love..." has been on long-term repeat on my player. (He's even better live; go see him if the opportunity arises.)

user avatar

mature writing and a perpetually youthful voice

panchodog

Well-said, whiskyprajer: "In spite of desperation, life affirming." Absolutely. These songs don't depress. They enlighten. And the title track is a masterpiece.

user avatar

Back On Track

EvilWoman

Serious subject matter treated with respect and always, wisdom. He has a great voice and I love his songs.

user avatar

Don't take this album away

Average-Nights-Jack

Terrific release from this Austin based genuine quality songwriter. Superb melodies and varied tempos provide a compelling backdrop to song very good songs. Some say grim, some say heavy, maybe so, but generally it's damn good music and I for one am not complaining about the subject matter or tone. One of my top 3 albums of 2009.

user avatar

Very good.. Heavy stuff

Cosk

Great production. Slaid has a great voice. Great CD. Intense theme .. Hit's home with me as my Father is getting old.. Slaid needs a 2nd home to get away from the cemetery next to his house. I suggest Key West.

user avatar

grimly life affirming

whiskyprajer

Although Cleaves' subject matter is frequently dire, his performance of it is humane. His characters can be cursed, or simply cussed, but there is a resolution to them all that is, in spite of desperation, life affirming.

user avatar

Great album - cheer up Slaid

Worth

the first song is a "every day closer to death" pessimistic song. Almost defiant in its' pessimism = "Cry for your Mama" saying cry and see what good it does you. The arrangements are well done and I recommend this album. Save it for a sad time.

user avatar

Loved this immediately

Grimey

It sounds familiar, but in a good way. Love the voice, the songs, and the hooks that stuck in my head instantly.

user avatar

Excellent

rastamon

Great voice, great songs, great production, but I didn't expect any less from Slaid and Gurf.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Music Guide

It is odd that Slaid Cleaves has allowed a bad but wildly popular novelist like Stephen King to write the liner notes for his album Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away, since, as a songwriter, he far more closely resembles a good but much less popular short-story writer like Raymond Carver. Of course, when a famous person offers to write an appreciation of you, it’s hard to refuse, at least from a marketing point of view. Unfortunately and inevitably, the notes are written in King’s semi-literate style; at least they’re enthusiastic. Nevertheless, Cleaves continues to make like a Southwest Raymond Carver on Everything You Love Will Be Taken Away, his first album of largely new material in five years. People on life’s fringes — including a high-school dropout, a cowboy turned drug runner and illegal-alien smuggler, a woman whose husband is away at war, another woman who’s abused by her husband and takes her revenge with a gun, and an executioner recalling the days of public hangings — tell their stories or have them told by the songs’ narrators, sung in Cleaves’ drawling tenor. Love and money always seem to run out, and violence is never far away. Drinking and drugging occur frequently. Life is hopeless, but people continue to live, at least for a while. Cleaves is particularly incensed about the wars that are luring young Americans away to be killed, maimed, or psychologically devastated, such that the political side of his work begins to recall Steve Earle. But it is the personal impact he is concerned with primarily. The stories are told over attractive folk/country/rock arrangements, which to some extent ameliorate the gloom. But these are not Stephen King-like stories of harmless fantasy-horror. They are tales of dead-end desperation told with the unflinching precision of Raymond Carver. Too bad Carver died 20 years too early to write his appreciation of Slaid Cleaves. – William Ruhlmann

more »