Either/Or

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (1257 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 12   Total Length: 36:57

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Ann Powers

eMusic Contributor

Ann Powers is the author of Weird Like Us: My Bohemian America and co-editor of Rock She Wrote: Women Write About Rock, Pop, and Rap. She is a former pop critic...more »

04.30.09
Elliott Smith, Either/Or
2009 | Label: Kill Rock Stars / Redeye

For a tiny moment it seemed that Elliott Smith was going to be the "new Dylan" of Generation X; his exquisite balladry so perfectly captured the wistful dance with hope and hopelessness enacted by the shadow children of the Baby Boom. But it wasn't to be, not only because of Smith's struggles with depression (which led him to suicide in 2003), but because Smith's moment called for something more subtle. Hear it on this exquisite disc, a homemade charm bracelet strung with anger and hope and lovely broken dreams. Smith was a lo-fi pop perfectionist — his melodies and simple song structures aimed to match the Platonic ideal of his heroes, the Beatles, but his arrangements were raw as punk, as was his fragile tenor. In love songs like "Between the Bars" and tales of cosmic disappointment like "Ballad of Big Nothing," Smith grasped the beating heart of that old ennui, the dark side of the indie rock spirit.

Write a Review20 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Prophet

musky3390

Hes a prophet, what else can be said about someone who puts life into words that make so much sense.

user avatar

Smith at his best

sunshine_daydream

Wtih its folksy, story-telling lyrics and intricate melodies . . . the first time I heard this album, I was hooked. "Angeles" is a dreamy, gorgeous track I truly couldn't live without. Download immediately!

user avatar

Hidden Gem?

Leo2727

I've never heard of Elliott Smith until recently. I've been missing out. This album is worth a listen, check it out...

user avatar

i pity the fool.......i really do.....

sameoldparadise

one of the most beautiful things i have ever come across.......music or otherwise........ you're a fool not to try this......

user avatar

One of the Best of the 90s

ceguru

While a lot of reviewers reference the Beatles, I've always thought it worked better to consider Smith as something of a 90s indie Nick Drake. His songs are haunting (occasionally harrowing) and yet the melodies and arrangements, even though simple are among the loveliest in the entire rock canon. (It's even possible to imagine the bouncy pictures of me flushed out and lurking on a Zombies record somewhere). Like Drake, I suspect Smith will find more widespread success when he is rediscovered by later generations. These songs are just too good, too beautiful and too well-constructed to not spark some sort of major reappraisal at some stage in the future. While all of Smith's albums are highly recommended, this is the place to start as it contains his strongest overall batch of songs, particularly "Between the Bars" "Angeles" and "Rose Parade"

user avatar

Actual punk. Actual folk.

disasteroid

I used think it was just way too Beatles infused, but you know? How bad a thing is that, and anyway, he twists it well.

user avatar

Emotionally gripping!!!

kuhntownkid

Take gut-wrenching emotion and combine it with intricate acoustic guitar-based melodies and you have another in the brilliant trilogy of initial albums by ES.

user avatar

hauntingly beautiful

ellawitch

his music still gets me. so sad but so beautiful.

user avatar

outstanding

mtechswamp

Outstanding from front to back. Each song paints a picture and the album flows as a whole.

user avatar

Oscar, schmoscar

Bobuar

Happy that Elliott Smith ended up getting the credit that he deserved, but what made his songwriting great is that he never strove to gain any sort of noteriety. Either/Or is honest, sweet, somber, and bitter. his suicide was sad, but not shocking.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

Elliott Smith’s third album sees his one-man show getting a little more ambitious. While he still plays all the instruments himself, he plays more of them. Several of the songs mimic the melody mastery of pop bands from 1960s. The most alluring numbers, however, are still his quietly melancholy acoustic ones. While the full-band songs are catchy and smart, Smith’s recording equipment isn’t quite up to the standards set by the Beatles and the Beach Boys. The humbler arrangements are better suited to the sparse equipment. “Between the Bars,” for example, plays Smith’s strengths perfectly. He sings, in his endearingly limited whisper, of late-night drinking and introspection, and his subdued strumming creates a minor-key mood befitting the mysteries of self. “Angeles” is equally ethereal — Smith’s acoustic fingerpicking spins out notes which briskly move around a single atmospheric keyboard chord, like aural minnows swimming toward a solitary light at the surface of the water. The lyrics are a darkly biting rejection of the hypercapitalist dream machinery of Los Angeles (it would make a great theme song for Smith’s label, Kill Rock Stars). Ironically, “Angeles” was included on the Good Will Hunting soundtrack, which won Smith the acclaim of Hollywood’s biggest, brightest, and best connected voting body, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences. Smith’s stock in L.A. soared after he took his bow at the Oscars with Celine Dion and Trisha Yearwood. It might have been more interesting had he sung “Angeles.” – Darryl Cater

more »