eMusic Review
For a tiny moment it seemed that Elliott Smith was going to be the "new Dylan" of Generation X; his exquisite balladry so perfectly captured the wistful dance with hope and hopelessness enacted by the shadow children of the Baby Boom. But it wasn't to be, not only because of Smith's struggles with depression (which led him to suicide in 2003), but because Smith's moment called for something more subtle. Hear it on this exquisite disc, a homemade charm bracelet strung with anger and hope and lovely broken dreams. Smith was a lo-fi pop perfectionist — his melodies and simple song structures aimed to match the Platonic ideal of his heroes, the Beatles, but his arrangements were raw as punk, as was his fragile tenor. In love songs like "Between the Bars" and tales of cosmic disappointment like "Ballad of Big Nothing," Smith grasped the beating heart of that old ennui, the dark side of the indie rock spirit.