Hometowns

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (696 ratings)
Hometowns album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 13   Total Length: 37:26

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Yancey Strickler

eMusic Contributor

05.26.09
In an aeroplane over Alberta...
2009 | Label: Saddle Creek

Nils Edenloff, the lead singer for the Rural Alberta Advantage, possesses a complete and utter inability to sing with any measure of distance or cynicism. With his nasal, earnest voice, Nils pleads, pledges, confesses, praises and laments. Give him a slice of history like the 1903 disaster in the Canadian mining town of Frank, Alberta that buried an entire town alive beneath a rockslide, bodies still dug from its ruins decades later, and what does he sing? "Under the rubble/ The mountain that tumbled/ I'll hold you forever/ I'll hold you forever," on "Frank, AB." There's an urgency to Nils and Amy Cole and Paul Banwatt, his bandmates. Absorb, experience, write an amazing song about it, repeat.

Hometowns, the RAA's spectacular, doe-eyed debut, isn't the stuff of teenage love, sappy love letters or rapid infatuation. The band sees love in its soup, for sure, but it's the very best kind: earnest and sincere, and honest in its limitations. Take the gorgeous "In the Summertime" and its heart-skipping refrain: "And once in a while/ I know our hearts beat out of time/ And once in a while/ I know they'll fall back in line," all of it delivered in a soft, stoned… read more »

Write a Review 30 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

bah!

f_k_o_s

Come on eMusic, make this available in the UK!

user avatar

Sorry....

QBoulevard

I downloaded this album because it got great reviews...I feel so bad saying this but I did not like the album. The lead singer is so frighteningly out of tune that I cannot bear to listen to him.

user avatar

Great Album

BluegrassSailor

Great album get it. But eMusic, to be fair, this album was re-released by a label in 2009. It's been self-released since at least mid-2008.

user avatar

Believe the hype

wright.jaw

I bought this album the day it came out on Emusic in 2008 and it's been love at each listen ever since. So much that it has never left the disc changer in my car since. Yes Nils sounds like NMH, but their songs are much more hopeful and light than NMH could ever be. Do yourself a favor and see them live, I just saw my 7th show in the last 18 months and came away blown away once again. Paul does more with less than many of his contemporaries could ever hope to on the drums and through their voices Nils and Amy truly evoke the feeling that yes, they do love the advantage that Alberta gave them...

user avatar

Hidden Gem

eaglezzz

Just discovered this album and WOW it is amazing. From start to finish this is an album that will be high on my listening list.

user avatar

on constant repeat!

trishpants

So I'm new to this band... I heard a couple tracks on lastfm a while back and decided to get this record. Yes, initially I was reminded of Neutral Milk Hotel, but only marginally...and that's not a bad thing. I'm really into this album right now. Seriously into it, it's been on constant repeat in my car, at work and on my ipod. The songs are tight, the singer's is the bomb and the drummer is a bad ass. Really looking forward to whatever they put out next.

user avatar

Raw

thelastleaf

A very raw, uninhibited, intense album. The way the drummer plays gives the record a jittery, jumpy quality that, for me, was at times unnerving. If you took old-school punk and neo-folk and mixed them up, it seems like this is what you'd get. Not my cup of tea, but I'm not a big fan of Neutral Milk Hotel either - and these two albums are pretty similar, as has been mentioned many times.

user avatar

Best Album Of 2009!

Grimlock

Wow, what a truly original sound. I can't believe this is a debut album. It's so addicting! With the exception of "The Air," every single song is my favorite. I want more...NOW!!!

user avatar

The drums ...

dp24344

This album's energy is infectious. The songwriting is tight, the vocals perfect. But it's those drums that will have you hitting repeat. Try to stand still during "Don't Haunt This Place."

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

What We're Listening To: March 2011

By eMusic Editorial Staff, eMusic Contributor

Remember, during the halcyon days of the video store, the "Staff Picks" shelf? The place where employees got to lobby for their favorite films, and the place where you could go for a reliable selection when you just weren't sure what you wanted to watch? We're taking that principle and running with it: eMusic is proud to present this regular, monthly roundup of our editors 'and members 'current faves. Whether it came out 30 years… more »

0

eMusic Selects: The Rural Alberta Advantage

By Yancey Strickler, eMusic Contributor

The Rural Alberta Advantage are Nils Edenloff, Amy Cole and Paul Banwatt. They come from Toronto (singer Nils Edenloff hails from Alberta, hence the name), and Hometowns is their first record, and it is a great one. Hometowns is a classic indie-rock record, both in aim and in result. Their songs sigh and exclaim, occasionally simultaneously, their emotions varied but the sincerity a constant. Certainly any comparisons to Neutral Milk Hotel have a germ of truth.… more »

They Say All Music Guide

With a name like the Rural Alberta Advantage and a debut album called Hometowns, one would hope for an unpretentious collection of amiable indie pop tunes filtered through the wistful lens of a Wes Anderson film, and that’s exactly what you get. Singer/songwriter Nils Edenloff, along with Amy Cole and Paul Banwatt, craft lovelorn postcards to small town heartache, beloved and embittered friends and family, blue collar hardships, and the great big world around them with the kind of wide-eyed gusto that’s extremely effective when played in front of a hundred sweaty, dancing kids at a house show in somebody’s rented basement, but dribbles out of a pair of headphones like a leaky faucet. All too often, that energy is lost when a talented young band like this enters the studio, and RAA do their best to transcend the limitations of their home recorded calling card, but that energy eating reaper follows Hometowns around like a cop car on a Saturday night. If there was an award for “Most likeable album of 2009″, RAA would win by a landslide. Nice try. Can’t wait to hear the next one. – James Christopher Monger

more »