Secret, Profane and Sugarcane

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (643 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION

Total Tracks: 13   Total Length: 50:58

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Michaelangelo Matos

eMusic Contributor

Michaelangelo Matos is a former eMusic editor and one of its chief contributors, a staff critic for Resident Advisor, and he writes for Spin, Rolling Stone, Vil...more »

06.02.09
Elvis Costello reaffirms his love for Nashville
2009 | Label: Hear Music

Elvis Costello was raised in Liverpool and has lived everywhere from Dublin to New York, but a good chunk of his heart belongs to Nashville. That much would be obvious even if Sacred, Profane & Sugarcane hadn't been recorded in that city's Sound Emporium Studio in three days and produced by Americana doyen T-Bone Burnett with a crack band of Nashville session all-stars including Jerry Douglas, best known for his dobro playing for Alison Krauss's Union Station. All you need to do is pay attention to the album's regret-soaked selections to figure it out.

None of this is especially surprising: Costello has been writing convincing country music since his career began. The year he began recording, 1977, saw both "Radio Sweetheart" and "Stranger in the House" issued as B-sides, and from 1981's Almost Blue, a country-covers album, to 2004's The Delivery Man, featuring co-vocalists Emmylou Harris and Lucinda Williams, he's recorded extensively in Nashville.

The songs on Secret, Profane & Sugarcane come from a wide assortment of places. A few are Costello collaborations with other writers, including Burnett ("The Crooked Line" and "Sulphur to Sugarcane") and Loretta Lynn ("I Felt The Chill Before The Winter Came"). A handful of others, notably the… read more »

Write a Review31 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Not What I Grew Up On

cbl413

definitely not his 70/80's mnatra that made him great. but definitely better than the big band burt bacharach crap. sulphur to sugarcrane got my interest and 3.6 & 10 have grown on me.

user avatar

why not?

schmo

Overall, I like this CD. I saw him perform most of these songs at Telluride, and it was classic. Gotta love the man!

user avatar

Whatever Mr. Costello wants to do

vilvodka

Mr. Costello wants to do a country album. I have no problem with this. Afterall, he is Elvis Costello. He can do whatever he wants. Mostly originals...some co-written with T-Bone Burnett. Add in one Loretta Lynn and one Bing Crosby cover. Some traditional country, some hillbilly folk, some bluegrass, and a drunken outlaw ballad or two. Together, it all sounds like it was a fun record to make.

user avatar

Alot of fun

alexashton

Best Americana done by a Brit, ever? While there might not be any comparisons that immediately come to mind, that's basically what it is. Elvis Costello certainly knows how to cross genres, and this is definitely no exception.

user avatar

A bit of a slower pace..

rkoerth

I Kept hearing "Sulphur to Sugarcane" on the radio and it grew on me. Low and behold it's the only Elvis Costello selection on here. lucky me.

user avatar

The Best Elvis Costello in Awhile

Bungelow_Ed

It has been 20+ yrs since EC had any relevance to me. I must say though that Secret, Profane and Sugarcane is a pleasant recording with some fine songs, mostly the covers. Download and enjoy.

user avatar

I don't know

rhymevigilante

I DL with no expectations, and I don't love it or hate it. It's different, maybe it will grow on me.

user avatar

It was alright.

rockin_hammer

Downloaded this for on of my kids. Don't know why they wanted it, but hey it was for the kids. But not to bad, just not my main style of music.

user avatar

great!

etoo

Great album. I put up a longer review but forgot to put stars, so this is a short version saying, wow.

user avatar

My favorite Costello ever

Linky

I love how Elvis just does his thing -- what's on his music-mind at the moment. This one is more country than I've ever heard him be, and extremely well done. I first heard track 1 on the radio, and had to call the station to confirm it was him and get the album name. It's very T-Bone Burnett, and all the "great" that that entails.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

Icon: Elvis Costello

By Douglas Wolk

Smart, angry and mercurial, Elvis Costello is one of the greatest living songwriters; for better or worse, he knows it. The man with the big spectacles (born Declan MacManus) is an exile everywhere he goes: an Englishman whose strongest work owes its greatest debts to American country and R&B; a new wave star who hated the term and the scene and has spent a lot of the latter half of his career working with classical… more »

They Say All Media Guide

Elvis Costello has spent the back half of his career flitting from style to style, recording everything from opera to R&B, but he avoided the country-folk of 1986′s King of America until 2009, when he teamed up with America producer (and fellow Coward Brother) T Bone Burnett for Secret, Profane & Sugarcane. By its very definition, country-folk seems straightforward, but the only thing simple about Secret is the speed of its recording. Costello and Burnett assembled an all-star acoustic string band — featuring Jerry Douglas on Dobro, Dennis Crouch on bass, Stuart Duncan on fiddle and banjo, and Jim Lauderdale on vocal harmonies — and cut the album in just three days, its swiftness similar to its knocked-out predecessor Momofuku. Secret, Profane & Sugarcane often bears its quick conception fetchingly, feeling loose-limbed and intimate, a record made simply because it’s fun to play, a sentiment that can’t quite be said of its songs. Surely, there are times where the humor is as riotous as those old Coward Brothers singles — Costello and Burnett have a ball on the bawdy travelogue “Sulphur to Sugarcane” and sweetly harmonize with Emmylou Harris on “The Crooked Line” — but Secret is frequently fussy, particularly on the songs Costello has carried over from his unfinished Hans Christian Andersen opera. The very presence of these songs (“How Deep Is the Red?,” “She Was No Good,” “She Handed Me a Mirror,” “Red Cotton”) suggests just how muddled Secret, Profane & Sugarcane is conceptually: it bounces all over the place, threading these stagebound tunes between a collaboration with Loretta Lynn and his take on “Down Among the Wine and Spirits,” which he originally wrote for Ms. Loretta, a rollicking leftover from The Delivery Man (“Hidden Shame”), a cover of Bing Crosby’s “Changing Partners,” the Burnett co-writes, a few new songs, and a reworking of Elvis’ old “Complicated Shadows.” Despite the occasional stuffiness, there’s a lot of good material here and it’s all executed well, but it’s hard not to shake the feeling that this is a collection of leftovers masquerading as a main course. – Stephen Thomas Erlewine

more »

Activity

  • 02.06.12 World Cafe Looks Back: Elvis Costello - Rebroadcast today for one day only - http://t.co/ypgsvAI9
  • 02.03.12 Elvis Costello - Listen to & order #ChimesofFreedom: The Songs of #BobDylan Honoring 50 Years of @Amnesty International http://t.co/qAeM5yVp
  • 02.01.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters Announce West Coast Dates on Spinning Songbook Tour - http://t.co/2gsXfdYR
  • 01.30.12 Elvis Costello - "And Now A Word From Our Georgia Correspondents"- http://t.co/uxmil8a7
  • 01.27.12 Elvis Costello Reinvents The Wheel! 2012 "Revolver" Spring UK Tour - http://t.co/HJ5XZrk3
  • 01.26.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters Announce West Coast Dates on Spinning Songbook Tour - http://t.co/2gsXfdYR
  • 01.23.12 Elvis Costello - Listen to & order #ChimesofFreedom: The Songs of #BobDylan Honoring 50 Years of @Amnesty International http://t.co/qAeM5yVp
  • 01.20.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters Announce West Coast Dates on Spinning Songbook Tour - http://t.co/2gsXfdYR
  • 01.16.12 Elvis Costello Reinvents The Wheel! 2012 "Revolver" Spring UK Tour - http://t.co/HJ5XZrk3
  • 01.13.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters Announce West Coast Dates on Spinning Songbook Tour - http://t.co/2gsXfdYR
  • 01.11.12 Elvis Costello - Chimes of Freedom - The Songs of Bob Dylan Honoring 50 Years of Amnesty International - http://t.co/Y2h8vzPj
  • 01.09.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters Announce West Coast Dates on Spinning Songbook Tour - http://t.co/2gsXfdYR
  • 01.06.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters - 25 things to look forward to in 2012 - The Irish Times - http://t.co/PtFDX6fT
  • 01.05.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters - Ottawa's Top Concerts in 2011 - http://t.co/obpBCZLi
  • 01.04.12 Elvis Costello & The Imposters - Our correspondent's list of best St. Louis concerts of the year - http://t.co/Q7neqwMg
  • 12.30.11 Elvis Costello - It’s only money, It’s only numbers, Maybe it is time to put away these fictitious wonders-Red Cotton - http://t.co/7MD4GZQJ
  • 12.28.11 Elvis Costello - “Woe betide all this hocus pocus, They’re running us ragged at the first attempt - National Ransom - http://t.co/k23EeTYA
  • 12.23.11 Elvis Costello - "Man goes beyond his own decision, Gets caught up in the mechanism" - The Scarlet Tide - http://t.co/1z7r7TJm
  • 12.21.11 King’s reign beneath umbrellas Hide pennies down in cellars And money pours down and yet Not everyone gets soaking wet http://t.co/nzQswybz
  • 12.19.11 “Next week there’ll be some fashionable new sin For each harlot and each puritan - American Gangster Time - http://t.co/h3z7KPul