Troubled, Shaken, Etc.

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (18 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION

Total Tracks: 13   Total Length: 54:06

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Kristina Feliciano

eMusic Contributor

08.03.09
An enigmatic headphones album that grows more evanescent with each listen
Label: The Social Registry / SC Distribution

If it had been made 30 years ago, Troubled, Shaken, Etc. would have been called a headphones album, the kind you hole up in your room to listen to while you examine the cardboard sleeve it came in. It's introspective and free-ranging, and you kind of just want to be alone with it and your thoughts. Or, at least, I did.

The people behind the music are the London-based collective Sian Alice Group, who have been labeled by some as shoegaze, but calling them that would be overlooking their other dimensions — influences and moods ranging from post-jazz and trance to baroque to plain and simple. Around the time they released their first full-length, 2008's 59:59, which featured guest appearances by 's John Coxon and Gang Gang Dance's Brian DeGraw, Sian Alice Group issued a skeletal four-song EP called The Dusk Line that consisted of nothing but piano and vocals. Good luck pinning these guys down.

And honestly, why bother trying? Just go with it — literally. Each Troubled song is its own little journey, sometimes purely instrumental, sometimes not. Heavy on the synthesizer, "Airlock" is astronaut music—a wordless space odyssey. "Close to the Ground" has a steamy, tribal… read more »

Write a Review1 Member Review

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Interesting...

Muse8

Interesting conceptually, and some intriguing instrumentation and arrangements, but the vocalist seems to waver in and out of key with her vibrato...

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

The second full-length from the Sian Alice Group on Social Registry is a logical extension of its 59.59 debut. Troubled, Shaken Etc is equally ambitious, yet it’s much more deeply focused as a recording than its predecessor. Vocalist/songwriter Sian Ahern and her London-based sextet have carefully constructed this 13 track, 53-minute set to draw the listener down into a hushed, deceptively minimal soundworld that paradoxically demands the listener’s attention albeit graciously. The whispering repetitive guitars, marimbas, and piano on “Love That Moves the Sun” create a sparkling, shimmering sonic beauty before she begins singing. Her voice is so lithe and slight that the listener, seduced by the song’s atmosphere, is compelled to listen with concentration to every word. This is followed by the slightly darker, droning, yet no less gorgeous “Airlock,” that in some ways is reminiscent of Yo La Tengo’s attempt at atmospheric pop. But the song unfolds so much more tentatively and deliberately that when a muted trumpet enters about a minute in, it’s as if the listener expected it all along, as it introduces the rest of the subtle surprises in the track. The melody in “Through Air Over Water” touches on the band’s fascination with the British folk of Fairport Convention, but it is also graced by the dark kiss of the early Velvet Underground. But the surprises aren’t all subtle. The all-too-brief “Longstrakt” carries within it a groove that recalls both the Motorik Krautrock of Neu! as well as the percussive — and progressive — heaviness of Pierre Moerlen’s Gong. “Close to the Ground” is its mirror image: over seven minutes in length — making it the longest entry here — it walks a line between droning free folk, retro-psych worship, Lindsey Buckingham’s more adventurous melodic moments, and the indie experimental feel of the Fuck Buttons. “Vanishing” is a funky, spacy, psychedelic rock tune with soul-jazz breakbeats. The bottom line is Troubled, Shaken Etc is an album: paced, sequenced, structured, and produced as such. It’s utterly lovely, feminine, and subtly adventurous. The listener is given a soft, quiet, sonic bedroom and allowed to dwell in there, a mental place where time is suspended and the outside world vanishes entirely, for close to an hour. – Thom Jurek

more »