Why There Are Mountains

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (172 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 9   Total Length: 44:46

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Chris Roberts

eMusic Contributor

09.22.09
A fever-pitch indie-rock debut with the wind in its ears and stars in its sights
2009 | Label: Sister's Den Records / Redeye

As a grand opener — and perverse choice for first single — "And The Hazy Sea" is one bold statement of intent. Beginning with falsetto cries straight out of "Monkey Gone To Heaven" then careening into a (slightly) more conventional rhythm, the song grabs the listener by the lapels from the get-go. It's a rollercoaster from there on out, the track veering and lilting from arch art-rock to drunken wig-out, briefly visiting most points between. As if to confirm its claim to be a kind of alternative, adrenalized, college-going "Bohemian Rhapsody", its six-minute journey stops halfway through, then starts over again. The message is clear: You will not be bored.

As it turns out, that opening promise holds true: Why There Are Mountains is feverishly peripatetic, racing through shifts in mood and time signatures as if the group is worried the plugs will be pulled before they've demonstrated their chops. The album rarely lets up, sharp savagery and coy sweetness consistently intertwined. At times, the record seems to be the work of three or four bands at once: Vocalist/guitarist Joseph D'Agostino is as cryptic and caustic as Malkmus in his prime, even when, as on "Some Trees," Brian Hamilton's synth ripples… read more »

Write a Review7 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Great debut

ccomerfo

This band hews closer to shoegaze roots, and is a great listen for long distances. Use Cymbals Eat Guitars in the car during stretches of scenery.

user avatar

meh

phthoggos

Hey Crunchbird, get over it. They signed to a label and the label re-released their debut album. This is how things work. Anyway, I like "Some Trees" but the rest of this is too low-key (i.e. boring) for me.

user avatar

Topographic!

twoxvols

While this album goes a bit heavy for me at times, it mixes in lighter moments to balance the album out perfectly. Overall, the album works without very few boring moments (with the exception of What Dogs See). I agree with the Wah-Wah moments, but the band definitely focuses on greating a sound more so then crisp clean music. In the end, the Wah-Wah moments don't overtake the album, they add to its topography!

user avatar

I call shenanigans!

Crunchbird

I downloaded this exact same album from eMusic with the exact same track list earlier this year ... the only difference was that it displayed a different cover image. Now my Downloads list shows Cymbals Eat Guitars in the artist list but NO albums or songs, even though the exact same music is still available here. I REALLY hate it when the labels use this kind of cheap ploy to prevent subscribers from re-downloading tracks.

user avatar

Do I hear some Tripping Daisy?

Subito

Fun album, not one to listen to over and over, and with wah-wahs and other guitar work, it takes me back to bands coming out of Denton, Texas in the 90s

user avatar

Epic.

BadScooter

An epic collection of songs - both musically and lyrically. Return of indie guitar rock, Pavement fans should dig this. Full of crescendos, each bigger than the last. Try Indiana, Wind Phoenix, Cold Spring, Living North, etc. Top 5 of 2009, no doubt.

user avatar

Massive!!

ejankins

Yo La Tengo guitar with The Format lyrics and vocals â?? a fine and powerful noise, a clear 09 favorite

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

Cymbals Eat Guitars steal brashly: “Cold Spring,” for example, ruptures into what the band could only have referred to in practice as “the Modest Mouse part,” all perverse locomotion and hoarse bleating, while the ramshackle wordiness of “Indiana” evokes Stephen Malkmus plainly, without reservation. Elsewhere rise great leviathans of …And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead guitarissimo and noble falcons of Sufjan Stevens brass. These guys are second-rate thieves, in other words, stealing at will but without the authorial command to make these goods their own. But, standards be damned, that doesn’t mean Why There Are Mountains isn’t also a lot of fun — particularly on opener “And the Hazy Sea,” which sends the aforementioned leviathans vaulting over passages of simmering quietude and scorched-universe howls, the sort of immediate classic that bands start first albums with. It’s the only song that manages to make its own statement, but even so, the band performs some novice alchemy elsewhere as well, transforming all the shameless pastiche into something of a reminder of classic indie rock’s greatness. They’re a far shot away from all that, but if nothing else, they prove they’ve got their eyes on the right destination. – Clayton Purdom

more »

Activity

  • 02.10.12 http://t.co/PWeJiHLn
  • 02.10.12 Etsy is amazing for vintage home decor and sci-fi LARP headsets....
  • 02.07.12 BAWSE RT @nancypelosi: #Prop8 ruled what we knew it to be: unconstitutional. Victory for equality & CA families! http://t.co/QNYeAxXK #LGBT
  • 02.06.12 Doing it at dreamland studios in Woodstock and the whole process is being filmed for Masters From Their Day http://t.co/fbDTehwz
  • 02.06.12 Y'all are gonna plotz when you hear our new single "Hawk Highway". We're recording it with @John_Agnello at the end of this month.
  • 02.06.12 beat me to it “@theantlers: So Tom Brady and Dexter are played by the same actor right?”
  • 02.05.12 right?! Go to Amadeus “@Megafaun: We love Gent! The best!”
  • 02.02.12 http://t.co/7JhLLO8P
  • 01.26.12 Thanks for tweeting about our video, @Youtube! You're neat. :)
  • 01.24.12 Just passively watched George of the Jungle starring Brendan Fraser while making a spreadsheet. Want to cancel HBO for the world.
  • 01.22.12 We'll be coming thru Austin with Cursive though. :)
  • 01.22.12 Just saw a bunch of blogs saying we're playing SXSW. That's very exciting news that is unfortunately not true. :/
  • 01.22.12 Nuts!! Good thing it happened last day of euro tour. Soaked a CEG tee shirt in blood !! Guitar vacation I guess... http://t.co/aBukqCbD
  • 01.19.12 Sorry that was Joe. Changing the Twitter password :( #grossbandmates
  • 01.17.12 ya about that “@BearInHeaven:said it before,but being among the first to hear your friends new record=the BEST thing about being in a band.”
  • 01.17.12 here ya go! @MILAGRESband http://t.co/5ESUrJHP
  • 01.15.12 Best place to buy a colorful snood in Oslo, Stockholm, or Copenhagen? Dunno where I'll have time to shop, but I'm on a #SnoodHunt.
  • 01.15.12 Just watched 4 german kids called In Golden Tears put on a very ”we're the next Coldplay” show in Berlin. #gamerecognizegame #holyshit
  • 01.14.12 If you plan to travel to Berlin, do yourself a favor and stay at the Michelberger Hotel. It's nice.
  • 01.13.12 Euro-Aaron doppelgänger doing sound in Berlin tonight. @bellwetheraudio