Good Evening New York City

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (259 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK // LIVE

Total Tracks: 33   Total Length: 123:26

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Barry Walters

eMusic Contributor

11.17.09
Macca hits a home run in Citi Field with this invigorating live album
2009 | Label: Hear Music

The concerts from which Paul McCartney's seventh live album is derived catch pop's beloved elder at a particularly notable place and time. They occurred at New York's recently completed Citi Field, the ballpark built a home run away from what was Shea Stadium, where the Beatles kicked off a new era of rock spectacles with a record 1965 crowd of 55,600. McCartney's three Citi Field shows drew nearly twice that in July 2009, when anticipation for the 9/9/09 release of both Beatles Rock Band and the Fab Four's remastered catalog was high. McCartney's last solo album, Memory Almost Full, had become his biggest mainstream hit in years (and supplied him with the quartet featured here), while Electric Arguments, his rawest experimental collaboration with Youth as The Fireman, earned him underground kudos. Drawing from those albums, his solo and Wings hits, and monumental Beatles catalog, this two-hour set faithfully recaptures both the simplicity and magnitude of McCartney at the aughts' end.

His arrangements here are humble. The most youthful Beatle had just turned 67, and his voice reflects that. It's emotionally most powerful on the quietest Beatle ballads, like "The Long and Winding Road" and "Blackbird," where the impact of… read more »

Write a Review22 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Paul isn't dead

scott0220

It's amazing a guy this age can still do it this well

user avatar

I was there

madformusic

He's still great live. Does the same songs and dialogue for every show but all the old timers do. Hate when he grafts one song to the end of another and some of the lennon/harrison tributes are heavy handed but the man can still sing. And some of his better solo songs are superb even if the albums themselves are uneven.

user avatar

Sorry to say ...

gulchradio.com

...none of the tracks I downloaded are really airworthy. Very disappointing. "A Day In the Life" is awful, The opening of "The Long and Winding Road" sounds like a mistake - nothing I heard excited me and made me wish to play it on my show - maybe these songs are better left alone. To be fair I rarely like live recordings, but I had hoped this would be one I would.

user avatar

Traitional and new twists on classics

Frankx

Loved the way Paul does the songs. A litle traditional and some new twists. The Lennon Tribute montage was cool

user avatar

Paul McCartney Is The Best

butterflychic82

Paul McCartney is still the best n I am hoping 2 someday c him in concert. 1 of his biggest fans... butterflychic82

user avatar

Still --- lovin' Paul!

felters

Old me, new iPod, timeless music!

user avatar

Paul McCartney Not Sounding Good???

Strange-World

This Beatles fan never thought that I wouldn't be recommending a PAUL MCCARTNEY album! But, it's true! He sounds stressed, and off his game! I'm sorry. But,that's the honest truth! I have yet to warm up to this one!

user avatar

great music...but 33 downloads?

EMUSIC-02083E4F

2 CD set + DVD costs 13.99 on Amazon, or just downloading the MP3 costs 9.49. My emusic plan is 35 downloads for 15.89...so it costs more to download the tracks here than to buy the actual discs, rip them myself, keep the cd as backup and in addition have the DVD? I like emusic, but I used to think they saved me some $$. Maybe this is just an exception.

user avatar

Supreme Live Performance

RickyRicardo

Everyone in the auditorium is singing along, and you will too when you download this live performance recorded in New York. If you close your eyes, and cross your fingers, and repeat "LET IT BE" you will be transported to "YESTERDAY." Every song is memorable and timeless. Thanks to eMusic for making this available.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Media Guide

Unlike its 2002 predecessor Back in the U.S., Good Evening New York City doesn’t cherrypick highlights from a tour, it commemorates a specific event: the inauguration of Citi Field — the replacement for the now-defunct Shea Stadium, where the Beatles played a legendary show in 1965 — in the summer of 2009. The circumstances may be different — different enough to lead to a Billy Joel cameo on “I Saw Her Standing There,” the piano man returning a favor from Paul, who played at Billy’s Shea-closing shows in 2008 — and McCartney might have two strong albums of new material to draw upon, but as an album, Good Evening New York City plays a lot like Back in the U.S. with a whopping 17 of its 35 tracks shared between the two titles. More importantly, the vibe is the same, with Macca delivering an expertly balanced and sequenced set with all the skill of the old pro that he is. Apart from the inclusion of “Mrs. Vanderbilt” and “I’m Down,” there are no surprises, either in song selection or performance, but no surprises doesn’t mean no satisfaction, and this is plenty entertaining, Rovi – Stephen Thomas Erlewine

more »

Activity