Hootenanny [Expanded Edition]

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (142 ratings)
Hootenanny [Expanded Edition] album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 19   Total Length: 48:17

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Sean Fennessey

eMusic Contributor

Director of Merchandising, emusic.com

01.12.10
The Minneapolis scuzz rockers flirt with pop songwriting to surprising, brilliant effect
2008 | Label: Ryko/Rhino

An early toe-dip into the mainstream and certainly a calmer effort than their debut — those cascading, percussive synths on "Within Your Reach" scream romantic '80s movie jam. But Hootenanny is still rippling with fits of distortion and dissonance. "Color Me Impressed" is their tightest song yet, but no less smug. "Everybody at your party, they all look depressed / everybody dressing funny, color me impressed," Westerberg groans at the outset. It isn't until the song's final 30 seconds that, for the first time, a singing voice emerges. Westerberg pushes past melody and into harmony, setting himself up for a far less ragged future. There's also an Easter egg that would predict the sound to come on "Mr. Whirly," a bizarre double cover that begins with Bob Stinson playing the opening chords of the Beatles' "Strawberry Fields Forever" then transitions into a messy remake of McCartney's "Oh, Darling." The band's Fab Four obsession would soon come to light, bearing their best work ever. Elsewhere, Minneapolis alt-weekly City Pages gets an extended shout out on "Lovelines" as Westerberg, over a slick, jazzy bassline from the then-16-year-old Tommy Stinson, reads verbatim from the personal ads, imbuing some charm and a wink in… read more »

Write a Review 4 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Still a Favorite

JustPlainLucky

This was the first 'Mats album I bought, although I had listened to copies of Sorry Ma and Stink. It still holds a special place in my collection. It contains 2 of my favorite songs, Color Me Impressed and Treatment Bound. Treatment Bound still makes me laugh, and if you have ever toured with a band, in a van, ya know what I mean.

user avatar

color me impressed

SemolinaPilchard

Their awesome first fling with pop delivers one of rock n' roll's finest tunes, Color Me Impressed. Run It!

user avatar

What a great transition!

soma316

This is the 'Mats' transition album: after the sheer rawness of "Sorry, Ma" and "Stink," the band was kind of at a crossroads: keep the same punk snarl or move forward and try to capture a larger audience? With Hootenanny, they manage to do both, and in doing so, manage to make the best record of their all-to-brief career. Check out "Within Your Reach" and "Color Me Impressed." Just a great album.

user avatar

My favorite Replacements album

NoelZevon

More than just the "joke album: some consider it, this one has the key tracks in the Mats' transition to (ahem) maturity: "Color Me Impressed," "Within Your Reach," "Willpower." Plust those "joke" songs are ferocious, especially "Run It" and "You Lose."

Recommended Albums