Sorry Ma, I Forgot To Take Out The Trash [Expanded Edition]

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (191 ratings)
Sorry Ma, I Forgot To Take Out The Trash [Expanded Edition] album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 31   Total Length: 64:06

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Sean Fennessey

eMusic Contributor

Director of Merchandising, emusic.com

01.12.10
A spastic, brilliant exegesis on frustrated youth in Middle America
2008 | Label: Ryko/Rhino

Snotty, slurry, spazzy; this is what the middle of America — Minneapolis to be exact — sounded like in the late '70s and early '80s. Looking for a shouting match they'd never win, the 'Mats, as they were affectionately known, recorded this relentless, slapdash album without a trace of guile. They're drunk and nasty and happy about it. Westerberg doesn't so much sing as caterwaul. And like a younger, more irresponsible Buzzcocks, only eight of the 18 songs here exceed two minutes (which got the band slapped with the hardcore tag). But even at just 20 years old, Westerberg had a way with pop structure. Nearly all of the songs on Sorry Ma have double meanings — though they aren't exactly mind puzzles. "I'm careless, careless / couldn't care less, care less," Westerberg sings on "Careless," an important distinction. Being something and feeling something are never the same. From "I Hate Music": "I hate music / sometimes I don't / I hate music / it's got too many notes." See, they contain multitudes. A ramshackle effort, but an essential document of frustration.

Write a Review 4 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Well worth it!

dmdstrhalo

While not my favorite album of theirs, it's a great deal here. This remastered version sounds great AND has a ton of bonus tracks. "If Only You Were Lonely" is a welcome addition to this version, and worth the 12 credits.

user avatar

THIS is what Punk Sounds Like

Satyrblade

A classic. No Punk collection should be without it.

user avatar

Their most underappreciated

Zotzedwriter

Well worth the download, particularly "Johnny's Gonna Die" (about Johnny Thunder), "Shiftless When Idle,"Don't Ask Why," and "I'm in Trouble" - plus the bonus track "If Only You Were Lonely."

user avatar

My record got warped.......

DesertED

Thanks E-music!!

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Icon: The Replacements

By Sean Fennessey, eMusic Contributor

"Like maybe the main act doesn't show, and instead the crowd has to settle for an earful of us dirtbags..." drummer Chris Mars wrote in an unpublished memoir, explaining his band's name. Dirtbags: that's probably the word for this sloppy, perpetually drunk but deeply affecting Minnesota quartet - comprised of frontman Paul Westerberg, Mars, guitarist Bob Stinson, and Stinson's kid brother, Tommy. Few groups have made such a drastic but inevitable evolution (some might call… more »