The Courage Of Others

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (132 ratings)

We’re sorry. This album is unavailable for download in your country (United States) at this time.

The Courage Of Others album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 11   Total Length: 41:59

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
James McNair

eMusic Contributor

01.31.10
The slowest of slow burners, brimming with sweet and affecting melancholia
2010 | Label: Bella Union / Republic Of Music

Two whole years in the studio; the jettisoning of an album's worth of material; financial and emotional pressures that threatened the band's continued existence — Denton, Texas outfit Midlake have been to the heart of darkness making this record, and you can hear it. Their keenly-awaited follow-up to 2007's Promethean pastoral The Trials Of Van Occupanther is an unmitigated triumph, its sweet melancholia truly — and at times disconcertingly — affecting.

Inspirational touchstones include venerable Brit-folk acts such as Pentangle and Fairport Convention, but with its haunting flute and quiet introspection, "The Courage Of Others" also evokes "Isle Of View," a somewhat obscure 1972 album by Jimmie Spheeris that Midlake singer Tim Smith has often praised. Making subtle use of bassoon, harpsichord and auto-harp, and featuring layer upon layer of thoughtfully-wielded acoustic and electric guitars, Midlake's third album is the slowest of slow-burners, but one also expects it will burn long and true.

"Acts of Man," one of nine songs that begins with gently-picked acoustic guitar, establishes a key theme that was also explored on Van Occupanther: namely front man Tim Smith and / or his characters' need to retreat from the crowd and modernity into — as another song title… read more »

Write a Review 14 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Gorgeous melancholy

Goldfrapper

Midlake were unknown to me before I discovered this, and I came to it via John Grant's "Queen of Denmark" (which is awesome). This is not quite as good, but it's still lovely. I echo the criticisms that it lacks some variety of texture and mood, but that's a minor point really. This is so '70s England' in its melancholy feel - think Justin Hayward with riffs and balls (no, I'm not being insulting!). I shall certainly investigate Van Occupanther, but this is a wonderful entry point to the band if you don't know them already.

user avatar

Beautiful

Dessieboy

Totally different to their last album which was totally different to the one before. Think Blue Oyster Cult meets early Genesis playing outside unplugged. The last album had a big wide americana feel to it but this feels like they've decamped to rural England A really different album for me well worth getting.

user avatar

A slow burner

GreenwichPaul

Occupanther was definitely an album of the decade for me and, like many others, I felt a huge disappointment hearing this. But, give it time, as it does grow. I prefer to listen to individual tracks rather than the album as a whole and then its easier to appreciate their fragile melancholy beauty. Listening to the album as a whole piece highlights its single main flaw - a lack of variety in tempo and atmosphere. I think this is a really good album but one that would have benefitted from a little more light and shade. The work loses impact listened to as a whole and would have gelled better as a listening experience with at few more uptempo pieces thrown into the mix. But this is definitely not the 'bad' third album some folks are saying it is; it just isn't the album it could, and should, have been, probably a bad move by a band at this stage in their career

user avatar

Give It Time...

MoycullenJohn

To call this record a grower is an understatement - it is absolutely beautiful and rewards repeated listening. It sounds like it could have come out of the LA canyons any time between '67 and '74 - believe me, that's high praise!

user avatar

Dreadful

bygjohn

An entire album of tracks that go tinkle-dribble-zzzzzz. Sorry if that sounds harsh, you should have seen the comments I deleted! It's bland, passionless and pointless.

user avatar

Massive letdown

richard.babington

After loving Van Occupanther and reading rave reviews about this intense, solemn follow-up, I honestly couldn't believe my ears when I heard it. I really wanted to love it but was just bored to tears by it. Self-indulgent, over-earnest, lyrically uninspired - quite astounding from an album so long in the making. Perhaps it will be a grower but there's too much other exciting music out there - I've not got the time to waste on it. Even the best songs sound like watered down versions of Roscoe. Ignore the rave reviews - the Pitchfork review gets it spot on.

user avatar

Dreadful

studebaker

I consider Young Bride one of my favourite tracks of the past decade but this is an utterly dire album. There is no variety, variation, purpose or life in any of the racks. It grinds on and on in a dreadful folk rock vein, totally self absorbed in its own misery. I don't have enough time left to devote to trying to find some glimmer of life in the smug tosh. The worry is if it's a harbringer of the demise of alt.folk? Deadly dull Seventies music like this has no future.

user avatar

music as sweet addiction

ROSIE1

At times this album is pure audio emotion. At first 'The Courage Of Others' feels dark and perplexing but it grows with each listen into a warm blanket of twisting melody and harmony. A brave and moving departure from its more accessible prdecessor this record is now firmly in the category previously known as 'glued to my turntable'.If it continues to improve with age it is destined for the years top five. Music to bask in.

user avatar

Give it time

Seamus65

Been waiting impatiently for this follow up to TTOVO and after several listens it still hasn't really grabbed me but then neither did TToVO. I'm prepared to give it time, so should you.

user avatar

Another triumph

Profbeaker

I loved Van Occupanther and I think this album will grow on me too - can't understand the negative comments as it sounds just as good, if a litle more folky than their last masterpiece. Download every track without fear.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Midlake

By James McNair, eMusic Contributor

"Why The Courage Of Others?" says Midlake frontman Tim Smith. "I guess because I could use some more courage myself." What Smith lacks in pluck, he clearly doesn't lack in tenacity, however, for he and his Denton, Texas-based band mates spent two years recording TCOO, the process involving the jettisoning of an album's worth of material, and all kinds of emotional and financial turmoil. The end result is something of a masterpiece; a darkly compelling pastoral… more »