Black City

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (260 ratings)
ALBUM INFORMATION
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 10   Total Length: 47:48

eMusic Review

Avatar Image
Adrienne Day

eMusic Contributor

08.03.10
Turns out the versatile producer-DJ can also write a mean pop song
2010 | Label: Ghostly International / IODA

Matthew Dear's 2003 debut, Leave Luck to Heaven, proved that dance music could appeal to the finicky indie-rock crowd, boasting songs that had just enough relatable elements — vocals, guitar — for those stuck in a "dance music = rave" mindset. (It didn't hurt that the sloe-eyed brunet is easy on the eyes.) Black City, Dear's fourth, largely excellent album, demonstrates that the versatile producer-DJ can also write a mean pop song — albeit a pop song that traverses an alien universe filled with sonic equivalent of boogymen.

On Black City, Dear has honed his singing chops to match his studio-production finesse. On previous albums, Dear's vocals played a mostly minor role, but here they sound like major plot points. City is slower than its predecessors; gone are the glitchy breaks that got Dear slapped with a "microhouse" label in the early aughts. That's not to say Black City isn't sexy: "I Can't Feel" rides a funky atonal bassline all the way to a squelchy guitar breakdown; "Little People (Black City)," the centerpiece of the album, uncoils deliberately over a brilliant nine minutes, morphing from 4/4 house to '80s synth-pop with an avant-punk twist. But Dear's City is a dark one,… read more »

Write a Review13 Member Reviews

Please log in before you review a release. Log in

user avatar

Matthew Dear's "Lodger"

wallbanger

Admittedly not a home run for Dear, this album nevertheless boasts at least 4 strong tracks: 3. Little People (Black City) 4. Slowdance 5. Soil To Seed 10. Gem. The title track 'Little People (Black City' is brilliant and reminds me of David Bowie's "Lodger." It is the lengthiest track clocking in at over 9 minutes, but that is it's strength. Given the room to stretch out, Dear really nails this track (as Britster remarked). As for the monotone critique, I think that's a little like saying Kraftwerk is monotone - it would be accurate but miss the point. But I can understand how one might hear it as an affectation. For me, I hear the techno influence on his vocals. Dear hails from suburban Detroit (Auburn Hills) and you can feel the city in his music. Overall a strong album that plays well as a complete listen.

user avatar

Add good Pitchfork review & pinch of salt

Britster

Gotta agree this is somewhat disappointing. The sound is lush and slick, the concept interesting, but the songs are way too dependent on Dear's repetitive monotone to go anywhere interesting. Seems like he expending most of his best ideas here on the one track: 'Little People (Black City)'

user avatar

Disaapointed

eJDL

Nicely produced, but the material is mostly... meh. Didn't meet expectations following 'Asa Breed' so the overt praise is lost on me.

user avatar

So good.

TDobs

So good.

user avatar

uninspired

robdeadtech

This record sounds like Matt Dear trying to make an indie-pop record. That's about all there is to it. Props for trying, but I just couldn't find much to grab on to. I feel like I'm only overhearing whatever he's saying from across the room, even though it seems maybe he's trying to talk directly to me. The connection just isn't there.

user avatar

Most Mature Release To Date

jofelony

The strongest, most cohesive, well-produced, lyrically and structurally mature album of his career in the pop context. I look forward to the next step under his birth name.

user avatar

Let it be known

UncoolMusicCritic

Okay, so Black City is a departure from his previous work, but I personally find it refreshing. I give Matthew Dear much praise for pushing the boundaries and moving forward. Let it be known that when an artist is stagnant they loose followers. Personally I really like this album despite "Pithchfork" praise, Bleep also make Black City a feature of the month. Buy this album. You won't regret it.

user avatar

Disappointing for Matthew Dear

katespinner

I love Asa Breed and Leave Luck to Heaven, but this is not nearly as fun or engaging. In fact, it is jarring when mixed at random with his other stuff.

user avatar

Let the backlash begin!

iangrey

It's been written into NYS law that loving this must be done lest your chance at writing unpaid articles for Pitchfork be forever ruined. At best okay. You want okay, this is yours. Spread the word.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

eMusic's Best Albums of 2010

By eMusic Editorial Staff

The 80 albums that populate eMusic's Best of 2010 run the stylistic gamut: There's skronking avant-jazz, surf songs for beachside loungers, grinding metal and delicate folk. What unites these records, though, is the personal vision behind each of them. It doesn't matter if the instrumentation employs guitars, djembes, sax or just the human voice — the albums on this list represent a dedication to a personal aesthetic, and the songs are the sound of that… more »

They Say All Media Guide

Black City is Matthew Dear at his least penetrable and most alluring. If the David Bowie comparisons were to continue, the album would place him somewhere in Lodger territory. The dominance of inscrutable lyrics, peculiar characters and subjects, and alien rhythms makes the album more akin to the likes of Lodger’s “African Night Flight,” “Yassassin,” and “Repetition” than the relatively straightforward “Boys Keep Swinging.” Like Asa Breed, Dear’s previous full-length, Black City is best described as avant pop, but there is an absence of lucidity, and no song sticks as quickly as “Don and Sherri” or “Deserter.” It’s all slippery, sleazy, murky sound-substance — knotted rhythms with irregular gaits made all the more surreal by Dear’s generally vague, suggestive lyrics and wordless, droning background vocals. Depending on your taste, this will likely be instantly off-putting or progressively pleasurable. Either way, it will probably make you feel like you could use a shower. That Black City is Dear’s most creative and individual album is not, however, up for debate. – Andy Kellman

more »

Activity