Critical Mass

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (95 ratings)
Critical Mass album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 8   Total Length: 72:50

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Dylan Hicks

eMusic Contributor

04.22.11
One of the great modern bandleaders and bassists in an unexpectedly optimistic outing.
Label: Dare2 Records / Sunnyside Records

Long tuned into to the avant-garde but not of it, always open to new and non-Western rhythms yet loyal to jazz first, bassist Dave Holland was leading the modern mainstream field before the term was a twinkle in some taxonomist's four eyes. For over 20 years, he's also been a staunch advocate of the collaborative, multigenerational working-band approach. Even a casual listen to his quintet's first album with new drummer Nate Smith will reveal that this is no pickup band — saxophonist Chris Potter and trombonist Robin Eubanks bounce off each other with the ease of prime-era Lewis and Martin, and the responsive rhythm section sounds made up as much of virtuoso listeners as virtuoso players. As usual, Holland shares compositional duties with the sidemen, and favors muscular ostinatos placed beneath urbane melodies. Critical Mass is sunnier than most previous Holland quintet outings — optimism even prevails on the New Orleans-inspired blues, "Easy Did It," a highlight along with Potter's "Vicissitudes," on which Steven Nelson, the group's ace in the hole, builds a sterling marimba solo around almost childlike three-note sequences.

Write a Review 3 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Best band

JoseNeville

This is the best band in Jazz today. The sound, arrangement, solos and composition are 5 stars!!!!

user avatar

One word "Vicissitudes"!

Voxman

I started with "Prime Directive", then "Not for Nothin'", and thought I ended with "Points of View". I then found "Critical Mass" here on E-music, and the rhythm of "Vicissitudes" would not leave me alone. The funk of it, and the syncopated voice-ings of the Potter and Eubanks duo along with the tongue-and-cheek battery work of Nate Smith (is he related to Smitty? With him bringing in the Eubanks', I'm beginning to think Mr. Holland likes to keep in the family) leaves me scatting the melody to top of my lungs. Talk about making my day go by fast. Keep puttin' the funk in my face Mr. Holland. Thank You!!!

user avatar

Great Music!

RBK1949

The Dave Holland Quintet returns with its first new disc of original music in 4 years. The only change in the lineup is the drummer Nate Smith and he's up to the task. Lots of tricky rhythms and splendid soloing across the board. Both Chris Potter and Robin Eubanks contribute great solos while vibraphonist Steve Nelson remains the unsung hero. His melodic/percussive edge always seems to be the right sound at the proper time.Nelson's composition "Amator Silenti" is an intriguing work that illustrates the Quintet's technical and emotional talents. Holland's compositions are as strong as usual and his underpinning allows drummer Smith plenty of creative space. Along with the new Lee Konitz/Ohad Talmor on OmniTone, this is certainly one of the best of 2006 (and beyond.)

Recommended Albums

They Say All Music Guide

One word that comes to mind when listening to Critical Mass is generosity. Double-bassist Dave Holland, four decades into his career, could certainly be forgiven for taking the word “leader” at its literal meaning, calling all the shots and keeping his musicians at bay. But that’s not what he’s about, and at any given time Critical Mass could just as easily have been credited to saxist Chris Potter, trombonist Robin Eubanks, vibist/marimbaist Steve Nelson, or drummer Nate Smith. Each player is provided with ample moments in which to take charge, and not fleeting, gratuitous moments but rather significant chunks of solo/lead space. Holland’s belief in sharing extends to the area of composition as well. Each bandmember contributes one piece to the album (Holland does claim the other four, however) and, more often than not, uses that opportunity to shapeshift, to push the band — and make no mistake, this is a band, not a random collection of studio players — into unexplored territory. That’s not to say that Holland takes a back seat — his presence is always strongly felt — only that he recognizes that the bass is, first and foremost, a support instrument and he’s content with using it as such when the piece calls for it. When he does step in to take the leadership role, he is endlessly creative, commanding in his ability to sidestep predictability and further his own legend. The particular mix of instrumentation here allows for numerous rhythmic and tonal variations as well: on the album’s longer pieces, in particular — Eubanks’ exploratory “Full Circle,” Holland’s appropriately hypnotic “Easy Did It,” Nelson’s multi-hued “Amator Silenti” — the quintet’s cohesiveness and utmost respect for one another becomes clearer by the minute. – Jeff Tamarkin

more »