Only in Dreams

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (203 ratings)
Only in Dreams album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 10   Total Length: 37:09

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Austin L. Ray

eMusic Contributor

For more than 10 years, Austin L. Ray has been writing about entertainment and culture. He's sat in a dark tent with Zach Galifianakis, walked Savannah, Ga.'s s...more »

09.27.11
Sounding cleaned up and positively huge
2011 | Label: Sub Pop Records

Previous to this, Dum Dum Girls’ second full-length after myriad singles, EPs and comps, it was a little too easy to group the California foursome in with the unwashed masses of the fuzzy-guitared, gloomy, lo-fi set. This year’s He Gets Me High EP hinted at a cleaned-up sound, but Only in Dreams runs with it, making good on a decidedly satisfying promise.

Vocalist/guitarist Dee Dee Penny’s pipes are so stunningly dominant — think halcyon-era Chrissie Hynde — that it makes sense that they’re not obfuscated by noise, but instead brought to the front leading all three other Dum Dums on harmonies to boot. Meanwhile, thanks to the production work of a notorious Jesus (and Mary Chain)-worshipper, Sune Rose Wagner of the Raveonettes (along with Richard Gottehrer), the band sounds positively huge. It’s a good look on them, that, when paired with their usual catchiness, feels like a child suddenly discovering a misplaced Christmas gift.

Also surprisingly counterintuitive is how upbeat these songs — which were inspired by Dee Dee’s mother’s passing, her time away from husband Brandon Welchez of Crocodiles, etc. — sound in comparison to the band’s oft-ominous catalogue. “You can tell me time will heal/… read more »

Write a Review 10 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

CAUGHT IN ONE

Flotasum

This album is what I have been looking for, for years. Pure earcandy. Thanks Dee Dee!

user avatar

step ya game up

musichead

only like coming down that's really good the other song's no comment could be alot better

user avatar

step ya game up

musichead

only like coming down that's really good the other song's no comment could be alot better

user avatar

Slump

cottser

Love the first album and the EP, but not feeling this album. Sad and samey.

user avatar

C'mon eMusic

ricardo222

...add The Pretenders to \"Roots and Influences\" or GTFO!

user avatar

meh.

cyncynl13

I was really disappointed with this album. I loved their first album and lyrics. It was original and spunky. It just doesn't sound like them at all. I don't expect them to not evolve but keep some sort of consistency. If you didn't tell me this was the Dum Dum Girls I would have never guessed. It is a very flat one note album in my opinion. Sad because I love them so much.

user avatar

vocals too modern sounding

starbearer

they really need to run those vocals through an actual echo chamber or something. the engineering style of the vocals are in way to much of a contrast to the rest of the mix. I think the vocal performance IS actually good. Just goes to show you though... a record is one half the band, and one half the people doing the recording and mixing. Check out the band Agent Ribbons. They are also very recent with that type of sound, but the vocal production was done correctly to match the style of the over all record.

user avatar

Walk like a Dum Dum.

James138

For a guy who really liked the garage rock 60s sound of the the old Dum Dum Girls this album disappoints. To me it sounds like the Bangles.

user avatar

Nice Update

KurtWerks

Their new producer, from The Raveonettes, really shines through and showcases this group. A first-rate outing and highly recommended, especially if you're a fan of classic pop.

user avatar

what a surprise

dramoscordova

The earlier records were ok, but i kept wishing they would find a new producer and clean up a likable, but messy sound. They have achieved that, in spades, with this release. The above review describes the vocals as Pretenderish and that seems an apt description, but with an edge that lends considerable depth to the poppiness. One of the best releases of the year and a very pleasant surprise.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

2011: Garage Rock Grows Up

By Mike McGonigal, eMusic Contributor

Four years ago, I flew from Portland to New York to see my favorite band, New Zealand's garage-pop trio the Clean, play three shows at a glorious pit called Cake Shop. The openers were Crystal Stilts, a Brooklyn group with no records out whose moody and noisy music pushed all the right buttons. I quickly befriended the group, especially guitarist JB Townsend and his then-girlfriend Frankie Rose, whose own band Vivian Girls were soon-to-be favorites.… more »

0

Kanine Records Radio

By Kanine Records, eMusic Contributor

Kanine Radio is a mix of the best songs of the '90s and new indie (2000s) bands that resemble that great '90s indie sound. In this mix you will hear a lot of my favorite songs from early in the '90s up until what I'm still getting excited about. The '90s were my favorite era of music, so it is no surprise that the bands that are turning me on now resemble that great '90s… more »

0

eMusic Q&A: Dum Dum Girls

By Marissa G. Muller, eMusic Contributor

Dum Dum Girls may borrow their aesthetic from '60s girl groups, but their crackling guitar-pop doesn't sound dated, especially when it touches darker themes. "This year's been a drag/ Who knew it'd be so bad," Dee Dee sings in "Caught in One" — and she's not kidding. Written during the last days of her mother's struggle with terminal cancer, Only in Dreams explores emotional volatility, but never surrenders or collapses. It is Dee Dee's most… more »

0

Six Degrees of Dum Dum Girls’ Only in Dreams

By Caryn Ganz, eMusic Contributor

It used to be easier to pretend that an album was its own perfectly self-contained artifact. The great records certainly feel that way. But albums are more permeable than solid, their motivations, executions and inspirations informed by, and often stolen from, their peers and forbearers. It all sounds awfully formal, but it's not. It's the very nature of music — of art, even. The Six Degrees features examine the relationships between classic records and five… more »

0

eMerging Artists

By J. Edward Keyes, Editor-in-Chief

At eMusic, we take pride in being the place you hear about artists first. Whether it's through our eMusic Selects program - which brought you the first releases by Best Coast, Crystal Stilts, Strand of Oaks and more - or our Breaking Artist features, our editorial team is always on the grind to bring you the best new artists first. Our eMerging Artists station is your chance to be first on the Next Big Thing. more »

Activity

  • 05.25.12 just wanna sleep but bouncing wavs for @RookieMag ................................. worth it
  • 05.25.12 Mt. Shasta weed chocolate sexy television
  • 05.24.12 Les Demoniaques lives
  • 05.24.12 Parting ways with @SISUband is tragic but getting to play with Kurt Vile on Friday is ... amazing.
  • 05.23.12 Listening to new @SISUband EP cuz @sandravu's not in the van -- gorgeous