Drumming The Beating Heart / Pale Hands I Loved So Well

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (13 ratings)
Drumming The Beating Heart / Pale Hands I Loved So Well album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 23   Total Length: 75:18

Write a Review 2 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Really good

vak78

I'm basically in total agreement with the previous review. I also came to this band via Bjork's All Songs Considered stint for NPR and can't believe I haven't heard of them before. There are some Joy Division sounds here, but the comparison is skin-deep. This band goes in a very different, but equally good, direction.

user avatar

Amazing

EMUSIC-017C0A0B

I had never heard of Eyeless In Gaza until Bjork played Throw A Shadow on a selection of her favourite music and now I can't get enough of them. I'm amazed they aren't more popular. This album grows and grows and grows and manages to maintain a fantastic point of balance between a sort of brooding tense aggression but at the same time a perfectly restrained melodic beauty, all in a pristine reduced package. It gives me the same sense of excitement that Joy Division does but in a totally different way.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Music Guide

A CD compilation of Eyeless in Gaza’s two best vinyl LPs (Caught in Flux and Rust Red September are close runners-up), this is a fine snapshot of the duo’s transitional period, from the minimalist early days into a sound that was noticeably more accessible but not quite yet pop. The reissue actually cheats a bit by putting the albums in reverse chronological order, with the much friendlier Drumming the Beating Heart first. Although this is still a duo with a deep interest in deliberate self-limitations — the pipe organ on the album’s front cover is the primary and at times the only instrument — Martyn Bates and Peter Becker are here experimenting with a much greater range of tonalities, and the pop song structures of songs like “Veil Like Calm” and “Throw a Shadow” are a new and fruitful direction. The icier Pale Hands I Loved So Well is supposedly largely improvised, yet it’s still more structured and melodic than what came before. The songs and brief instrumental sketches are delicate miniatures, but the best ones, particularly “Pale Saints” and “Light Sliding,” have much more in the way of melodic invention than Eyeless in Gaza had previously evidenced. This first CD issue also has much better sound than the notoriously muddy original LP, pressed on a tiny Norwegian label. – Stewart Mason

more »