Let the critics eat cake.
Mind you, I've only listened to the 30 second clips but I can tell you that the All Media Guide review is ridiculous in its offhanded, throw-away review. Will you find some of the same sound of past GBV albums. Sure. Many of the songs aren't lo-fi, in fact seem to have rather thick production. (And that's not a criticism.) Some of these songs I suspect The Beatles would have loved to create. John Lennon, at least. I say that with reservation, as I find Beatle-mania to be rather tiresome. (That has nothing to do with their music.) I didn't know GBV had a new album coming out. I'm psyched to listen to it given the bits I've heard. And I think I heard some things that lead me to believe that they've gone even deeper, rather than this being simply some fait accompli new album from an old band.