We Must Become the Pitiless Censors of Ourselves

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (13 ratings)
We Must Become the Pitiless Censors of Ourselves album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 11   Total Length: 32:01

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Marc Hogan

eMusic Contributor

Marc Hogan has been occasionally getting paid to write about music since 2003. His music writing has appeared, with enormously varying degrees of regularity, in...more »

12.23.11
Updating gothic '80s synth-pop for an alternate universe
2011 | Label: Ribbon Music / Domino Recording Co

If Ariel Pink was the godfather of chillwave, his CalArts pal John Maus must be its eccentric uncle. Only instead of, say, scratch-building model trains, this scholarly small-town Minnesotan updates gothic ’80s synth-pop for an alternate universe where Ultravox outsold Michael Jackson. With booming vocals, exaggeratedly artificial shimmer, and medieval melodic touches, Maus’s first widely distributed album packs enough deranged karaoke fodder to render its world hyper-real. His cold-blooded delivery (“Quantum Leap,” “Cop Killer”) makes it hard to tell whether this should be terrifying or hilarious. On gorgeously uplifting finale “Believer,” it’s simply inspiring.

Write a Review 2 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Terrible

METHODATTACK

This album is dull, derivative, and unlistenable. For you young hipsters reading all the head-in-the-clouds positive reviews of this: Go buy a Joy Division or early New Order record instead. Anything by them is a thousand times better than this.

user avatar

sounds like. . .

Benthos

. . . a way less grounded New Order (not as dark as Joy Division.) I like Cop Killer and the opener.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

They Say All Music Guide

On his third album, John Maus continues his pursuit of immediacy-in-action mixed with a certain calm, developing a further tension that infuses both his music and words. The immediately cheery lead synth sparkle of the opening “Streetlight” contrasts with both the melancholic background tones and his heavily echoed singing, suggesting above all else an uneasy joy in the moment, as if everything were being celebrated under a microscope or through gun sights. For all the ’80s-redux claims often pushed in his direction, Maus’ looming dread is much different from the nuke/AIDS paranoia of the time — there’s a sense of a new kind of rage against a dying of the light, a reaction against entropy. Whenever something starts seems sweetly winsome or romantic, as “…And the Rain” does (in its title alone almost directly referencing the early solo work of John Foxx), something else slides in to cause a darker cloud to bubble up — in that song’s case, it could be the wordless vocal breaks, but that’s one addition of many throughout the album. High energy — or even more literally Hi-NRG — tracks like “Keep Pushing On” rub up against slower ballads like “Hey Moon,” but all throughout Maus maintains his reserved, swathed voice, occasionally matching the music with a quicker pace but otherwise more seeming to soothe here. Even a song titled “We Can Breakthrough” is less charge than steady if strong progression, a sense of an unstoppable force lost in the texture but never fully quashed, voices carried along. As for “Cop Killer” — an original song, though there’s an inevitable association with the Ice-T/Body Count song and controversy of the same name — the slow beauty of the arrangement and the serene way Maus sings about who should be up “against the wall” makes it its own attractive, unnerving effort. – Ned Raggett

more »