Mean Everything To Nothing

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (147 ratings)
Mean Everything To Nothing album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 12   Total Length: 51:37

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Matthew Fritch

eMusic Contributor

11.24.09
Look out, Jim James — there's a new standard-bearer of arena-sized Southern rock in town
2009 | Label: Favorite Gentlemen/Canvasback

Look into the crystal ball at next year's Bonnaroo festival and you're likely to see My Morning Jacket and Kings Of Leon backstage, biting their nails and shaking in their boots. Atlanta five-piece Manchester Orchestra is warming up the crowd but running a little too hot, playing songs from third full-length Mean Everything To Nothing, the new standard-bearer of arena-sized Southern rock. Manchester Orchestra surely didn't set out to dethrone Jim James or the Followill brothers, but you don't record an album like this and not expect an upheaval. Mean Everything To Nothing is an immediately satisfying display of grunge-era guitar crunch and 22-year-old frontman Andy Hull's Cobain-esque sneer, which means — you guessed it — a Nirvana comparison and the requisite helping of angst-ridden lyrics. But things aren't as black-and-Bleach-ed as they might seem; Hull, a preacher's son who began writing songs for Manchester Orchestra while in high school, is charting his own coming-of-age course. He wrestles with God and himself, by turns funnily agnostic on "In My Teeth" ("Jesus is coming/He acts my age") and seeking answers on "Shake It Out" ("I felt God lead me into my home/Don't stop, don't ever go"). On "I Can Feel A… read more »

Write a Review 6 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Overwhelmed

coho

I dl'd this album and then shelved after one listen. I don't know why?!?!? I was completely blown away when I finally gave this album the listen it deserved. I hope MO's third effort continues the excellence.

user avatar

Wow!

Strattki89

Where have you been all my life? One of THE best albums I have listened to.

user avatar

They sure have the right formula

alexashton

This isn't mind-blowing, but it's certainly catchy enough to break them through. I'm surprised that "I've Got Friends" didn't become one of the bigger singles of last year. Anyway, this is still worth a listen and before you know it you're going to find yourself subconciously singing along to a few of these jams any time you hear them, much like Kings of Leon or Cage the Elephant.

user avatar

How Overlooked

ashleycwoods

Found this album on SPIN's 10 Overlooked Albums of 2009 list. Thank god. I'm listening to the samples song by song, and it ROCKS. Straight-up, no gimmicks. And not Kings of Leon wannabe-U2-2008 rocking, but ACTUAL rocking. With vocal restraint (no Followill howling!)! And they can really play their instruments! The Sex isn't On Fire, the guitars are. Sorry for all the KoL references, but I really wish that I could have heard these songs on the radio 838393 times this year. I could use somebody like Manchester Orchestra. :) So could someone like you!

user avatar

Tied for Album of the year

fathomfurline

This ranks at top album for 2009 along with Paper Route's Absence in my book.

user avatar

Absolutely perfect

andytuck

I would easily place this in my top 5 albums ever. Every track is incredibly powerful and the melodies are the pinnacle of rock. If you want to try out a few tracks, I recommend "I've Got Friends" or "The Only One", although the entire album is fantastic. I think it is only a matter of time until this album has 1000+ ratings on eMusic, and if it doesn't, then shame on us all.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Big Ugly Yellow Couch Radio

By Big Ugly Yellow Couch, eMusic Contributor

Big Ugly Yellow Couch is an acoustic video series run by photographer Donald Rasmussen and writer Carlye Wisel, two goons with an ugly piece of furniture and a relentless desire to help expose unbelievable artists to energetic fans. Stemming from the idea that phenomenal music can be stripped down to its core and remain just as impressive, the duo seek out bands they love-love-love-love, and record stripped-down sessions on a dead old lady's couch they inherited… more »

They Say All Music Guide

Atlanta’s Andy Hull and company received considerable praise leading up to Mean Everything to Nothing, Manchester Orchestra’s second official full-length release. With that praise and hype came the attention of producer Joe Chiccarelli (the Shins/My Morning Jacket), who adds enough muscle, sound, and fury to the music to match Hull’s frequent growls and rants. The resulting dynamic attack will likely please the screamo crowd, as songs like “Shake It Out” feature the kind of angsty lyrics (fighting the Lord), yelping Isaac Brock meets-nu-metal-swagger, and power chords that thrill a young audience. More savvy, or at least older, music fans will be able to pick out the influences, from the Kurt Cobain wail and Nirvana-like grunge pop of “In My Teeth,” to the Smashing Pumpkins-by-way-of-Jane’s Addiction guitars of the catchy and earnest “I’ve Got Friends,” to the wounded-voice Bright Eyes of “The River,” to the all-out Neutral Milk Hotel borrowing that is “100 Dollars.” – Tim DiGravina

more »