Movement [Collector's Edition]

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (199 ratings)
Movement [Collector's Edition] album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 18   Total Length: 89:40

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
J. Edward Keyes

Editor-in-Chief

J. Edward Keyes has been writing about music for nearly 15 years, a fact he occasionally finds terrifying. His work has appeared in Rolling Stone, the Village V...more »

03.01.10
A band felled by tragedy, proceeding the only way they know how
2008 | Label: Rhino/Warner Bros.

Ian Curtis at his bleakest wrote, "Guess that dreams always end/ they don't rise up, just descend," so it's probably not for nothing that the first song on the first album his bandmates wrote and recorded without him is called "Dreams Never End." The song itself is a little marvel — it retains all of Joy Division's minimalism, but the tone is markedly brighter. After its initial opening stammer, the song revs up to full-cruise speed, providing a crude template for the melodic grandeur that would inform later New Order songs (and also acting as an obvious touchstone for the Cure's much-later "Just Like Heaven"). It's clear the band still wasn't sure what to do with themselves: Bernard Sumner (and Peter Hook, who takes lead on "Dreams" and "Doubts Even Here") were shoving their voices way down into their throats, as if trying to ape Curtis's unmatchable groan. Traces of the funereal gloom of Closer liner in the lonesome melodica and organ lines of "Truth" and the stark "Transmission" rewrite "I.C.B." (or, "Ian Curtis Buried"). The band again teams with producer Martin Hannett, but without Curtis at the fore, the entire album feels strangely vacant. It's a stark… read more »

Write a Review 3 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

first and favorite

starbearer

their first is for sure my favorite. The ghost of Ian Curtis can still be felt, and at the same time a new soul for the band is being born. its a deep album.

user avatar

Uplifting

ChristyMathewson

If you're feeling down about the world, consider listening to this album. The great Joy Division seemed beaten in 1980, singer Ian Curtis dead, but here they were again as the New Order. Listen to all the ideas here, a female keyboardist added, and know that a couple years later, "Blue Monday" (per Wikipedia best selling 12-inch single of all time) would be created.

user avatar

classic and lovely

velvetoverground

new order at their best!!!! right after joy division.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Cold, Dark and Minimal

By Andrew Parks, Director of Merchandising

Thanks to synth-heavy, eyeliner-optional labels like Minimal Wave and Wierd Records the world's never been safer for the black-lit side of the indie/dance spectrum. Cold, Dark and Minimal pairs the finest minimal/cold/dark-wave reissues with the rising stars (Light Asylum, Soft Metals, Xeno & Oaklander) and standbys (New Order, Depeche Mode, The Cure) of the not-quite-goth scene. more »

They Say All Music Guide

Movement is the first hesitant step in the transition from Joy Division to New Order. Despite a relatively assured debut single (“Ceremony,” which didn’t even appear on the album), the first New Order album revealed a band apparently caught up in mourning for its former lead singer. (But of course, themes of loss and isolation were hardly novel for them.) Movement encompassed songs written just after the suicide of Ian Curtis, and it was recorded with alternating vocal spots to see whose would fit best — although neither Peter Hook nor Bernard Sumner sounded worthy of the mantle. (At times, their hesitancy makes it sound as if they were recording guide vocals for a Joy Division LP, expecting Ian Curtis to come in later.) Despite the band’s opaque lyrics, critics and fans were spotting references to Curtis all over the record, with despair and confusion reigning especially on “Senses” (“No reason ever was given”) and “ICB” (“It’s so far away, and it’s closing in”). More so than on any Joy Division record, it also revealed a group unafraid to experiment relentlessly in the studio until it had emerged with something unique. Spurred on by producer Martin Hannett, despite his antagonistic relationship with the band (and perhaps, because of it), New Order produced a ghostly, brittle record, occasionally uptempo but never upbeat, with drum machines rattling and echoing over dark waves of synthesizers and Hook’s basswork. A masterpiece in the career of any other post-punk band, Movement only paled in comparison to the band’s later work. [Rhino's 2008 remastering of New Order's first five albums, subtitled The Factory Years, provided complete remastering of each original LP plus a bonus disc that included a good sampling of the band's non-album material contemporary to the album. For Movement, that means both sides of their critical 1981-1982 singles ("Ceremony," "Temptation," "Everything's Gone Green") plus alternate versions of "Ceremony" and "Everything's Gone Green."] – John Bush

more »