BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 3 in E flat major, "Eroica" / Symphony No. 8 in F major

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (43 ratings)
BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 3 in E flat major,
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 8   Total Length: 76:15

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
James Jolly

eMusic Contributor

04.22.11
A master’s reinvention of the symphonic form.
2006 | Label: BIS

Beethoven's Third Symphony, subtitled the "Eroica" ("Heroic"), reinvented the genre. The first two symphonies are recognisably from the same stable as the late symphonies of Haydn and Mozart, but with this work, Beethoven literally exploded the form and range of what a symphony could do. The two dramatic chords at the start immediately hint at something new and arresting: what follows is a movement longer than many entire symphonies up to that point. The struggle, so central to Beethoven's music, takes centre-stage and the instruments are called upon to clash in ways that must have shocked its first listeners. Then there is the Funeral March second movement, an extra-musical association that makes the dancing scherzo (third movement) and finale even more arresting. This new Minnesota performance (coupled with No. 8) is shattering, and wonderful proof that Beethoven's music will be as relevant to his listeners'day as to his own.

Write a Review 4 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Damn Fine

Mabeuf

Excellent interpretation of both symphonies. Vanska is a master. I love his Sibelius works and his Beethoven is just as good on par with Szell, Bohm or van Karjan.

user avatar

Excellent, but...

beethovenmozartbrahmsschubertetc

Like the other Vanska/Minnesota Beethoven Symphonies, these performances are in my opinion excellent except that some of the soft passages are TOO soft. An example is in the first movement of the Eroica: the violins/French horn moment right before the recapitulation. There are many other examples. Of the dozens of other Beethoven conductors whom I have heard, none does this, and I doubt that Beethoven would approve of this exaggerated softness.

user avatar

Not revelatory but still pretty fine

SpinyNorman

There has been no shortage of critical acclaim for these performances. Having said that, I feel that they are very good rather than revelatory. It is fair to say that Vanska has some individual touches, particularly in the Eroica, although we are not really convinced that those relating to dynamics are any more than mannerisms. As with other issues so far in this cycle, the playing of the Minnesota band is technically beyond reproach, and this orchestra is seemingly benefiting from Vanska’s appointment as its music director. The sound is full and spacious, and especially good in the eighth, which verges on excellence.

user avatar

Vanska's Eroica

LobsterClassics

See other reviews about this recording on the internet - most seem impressed. e.g. see http://www.highfidelityreview.com/reviews/review.asp?reviewnumber=18447604

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

A Beginner's Beethoven

By James Jolly, eMusic Contributor

When people talk about the great classical composers, three names inevitably crop up: Bach, Mozart and Beethoven. Bach, the great composer of unshakable Protestant faith, a master of form whose music embraces the sublime; Mozart, the great portrayer of the human condition, the master of perfection whose music caresses our hearts and souls; and Beethoven, the first great Romantic, the man whose music grapples with Destiny. The life of Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827) spanned the turn… more »