Automatic For The People

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (1020 ratings)
Automatic For The People album cover
Album Information
EDITOR'S PICK

Total Tracks: 12   Total Length: 48:37

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
J. Edward Keyes

Editor-in-Chief

J. Edward Keyes has been writing about music for nearly 15 years, a fact he occasionally finds terrifying. His work has appeared in Rolling Stone, the Village V...more »

01.11.10
R.E.M.'s masterwork
1992 | Label: Warner Bros.

A haunting rumination on mortality, Automatic for the People is R.E.M.'s late-period triumph and the pinnacle of their major-label career. Widely regarded as the group's best effort (an assumption that is up for no small amount of debate), Automatic finds the group at their most beautiful. Sporting string arrangements from Led Zeppelin's John Paul Jones, Automatic continues the largely acoustic approach the group began exploring on Out of Time.

All of this ornate instrumentation serves to support grim subject matter. If "Smells Like Teen Spirit" provided a blistering summation of prevailing teenage disaffection, "Drive" was its cautious older brother. An inversion of David Essex's "Rock On," Stipe uses its lyric to explore the kind of rebellion born of confusion — his declaration "Hey, kids, rock and roll, nobody tells you where to go" is more lament than celebration. Perhaps that's because he's more concerned with the end of life than its mid-period: much of Automatic finds him mulling over mortality. Parents are buried, suicide is considered, and Andy Kaufman and Montgomery Clift assume the stature of martyrs. It's a tremendous credit to Stipe that he can pull off such weighty ruminations without being obvious or overly dramatic, and that his reaction… read more »

Write a Review 9 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Ummm .... excuse me??

Bribook

I know everybody hears something different when they listen to music, but ChuckT808, COME ON. \"Nightswimming\" is a \"throwaway?\" I say it's one of the three best songs on the album, and few would debate me on that. I do think \"Automatic\" has more in common with \"Out of Time\" than most R.E.M fans would want, but I say the similarities are mostly positive. You might say the vocals on \"The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonight\" are soulless, fine, but what about \"Everybody Hurts?\" What about \"Monty Got A Raw Deal?\" What about \"Ignoreland?\" What about \"Man On the Moon?\" BTW, I LOVE \"Sidewinder,\" so there you go. This is not only one of R.E.M's best albums, but one of the best discs I own, and I have thousands.

user avatar

Masterwork, if radio-friendly pop is your thing.

chuckt808

The key phrase from Stephen Erlewine's All Music Guide review of this album is "the pinnacle of their major-label career" with an emphasis on "major-label." While definitely retreating from the hyper-pop stupidity of Out of Time, this album still manages to make what was once great about REM seem rushed and trite. Stipe's vocals on The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite are easily the most soulless to ever appear on an REM album. Give it a listen and then listen to anything from Life's Rich Pageant and you should quickly hear the difference. The rest of the hits, while definitely not "Happy Shiny People," are still just the same stripped-down pop. REM has several albums where nearly every song is listenable while Automatic for the People seems to only have pop hits meant to be radio singles (Drive, Man on the Moon) and throwaways (Star Me Kitten, Nightswimming) and I've never heard anyone say, "I LOVE New Orleans Instrumental No.1!" which is actually quite interesting and listenable.

user avatar

Still holds up

Macklind

to the test of time. I remember this album wasn't heavily hyped -- walked by a record store and saw the poster advertising it...bought it right away of course. This album has all of the gracious R.E.M. sounds: mandolins, piano, gorgeous string soundbeds, jangly guitar. It evokes the emotions of autumn, leaves turning gold, a hint of sweet, cool air. It is a melancholy yet hopeful album. Great one to play at night, driving down rural roads, with all windows open, your hand dangling out and touching the October wind.

user avatar

My favorite Bands Best Album

mpgoroff26

REM couldn't record a bad album through the mid-90s with multiple masterpieces including Murmur, Document, and Reckoning. However this album is their peak as everything they did from Byrd's inspired Southern Rock (Murmur), Political Punk (Document), and country instruments (Mandolins on Out of Time). Album contains gems such as Man on the Moon (supposedly Stipes favorite song), Drive, Everybody Hurts, and The sidewinder Sleeps Tonight

user avatar

My Least Favorite...

jaw2ek

There's good songs here, but the hits are so glib (yes, I said it!)

user avatar

No it's really good ...

EMUSIC-type

I only heard these guys sometimes and missed a lot of their stuff. This collection is catching me up and telling me I need more. For all you guys that have known about them forever, good for you. For the rest of us, this is reason to hunt up the rest.

user avatar

definitely not their masterwork, at all

chachlate

not to belabor the point, but i can name a half dozen albums of theirs off the top of my head that trump this one easily: Reckoning. Fables. Green. Document. Murmur. Lastly, the dark horse, New Adventures in Hi-Fi. Come on, emusic dudes. I mean, this is a good album and everything, but it has some real clunkers on it when compared with the rest of their incredibly wide and deep catalog. It's a disservice to this band to call it their masterwork.

user avatar

Still Not Better Than Early REM

Nyabinghi

I find myself in agreement wit Ross. I absolutely loved their early records which culminated with their best record, Life's Rich Pageant. At that time they had already expanded their sound to stadium rock. By Document, my interest had waned. Out Of Time is lame. Automatic made me take notice again; A great Album!

user avatar

Masterwork? Masterwork?!!

ROSSFIGHTS

I grew up listening to this band, so I was able to watch their journey from obscurity to stardom. This is the following album to their meteoric rise to the radio with "Out of Time". This is a great album, but to me this is REM playing to the pop masses more than previously. The best tracks are 1,2,6,and 11. "Nightswimming" is one of my favourites of theirs. Just stay away from "Man on the Moon" which makes me want to slap someone, don't be that guy.If you want to check out their masterwork, try "Life's Rich Pagent".

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Banging on the Pots and Pans: Songs for Kids and their Parents

By Sujan Hong-Raphael, Senior Manager, Label Relations

With songs about airplanes and trains, counting and clapping, and of course, a funky penguin, Banging on the Pots and Pans features all ages, genre and era-spanning tunes that are kid-tested, mother-approved. You'll hear classic cuts from Rufus Thomas, Shirley Ellis and the Pointer Sisters, newer favorites by the Apples in Stereo, Young Fresh Fellows and Luv Clowns as well kid-friendly tracks from the White Stripes, Bobby Charles and Brian Wilson. All together now! more »

They Say All Music Guide

Turning away from the sweet pop of Out of Time, R.E.M. created a haunting, melancholy masterpiece with Automatic for the People. At its core, the album is a collection of folk songs about aging, death, and loss, but the music has a grand, epic sweep provided by layers of lush strings, interweaving acoustic instruments, and shimmering keyboards. Automatic for the People captures the group at a crossroads, as they moved from cult heroes to elder statesmen, and the album is a graceful transition into their new status. It is a reflective album, with frank discussions on mortality, but it is not a despairing record — “Nightswimming,” “Everybody Hurts,” and “Sweetness Follows” have a comforting melancholy, while “Find the River” provides a positive sense of closure. R.E.M. have never been as emotionally direct as they are on Automatic for the People, nor have they ever created music quite as rich and timeless, and while the record is not an easy listen, it is the most rewarding record in their oeuvre. – Stephen Thomas Erlewine

more »

Activity

  • 05.26.12 Big Star Tribute in London on May 28th at Barbican @BigStarBand http://t.co/XfWJeoJ3
  • 05.07.12 Check out Michael on Tumblr: http://t.co/ruxeM27n
  • 05.06.12 Congratulations to good friend @HughAcheson of Athens for his James Beard Award for A New Turn in the South http://t.co/b0EQFU4h
  • 05.04.12 Check out this new song celebrating Amnesty International's 50th anniversary: http://t.co/PaGUl75k
  • 05.03.12 Check out Mountain Stage on NPR this weekend featuring Patterson Hood and friends: http://t.co/zBVpqfR5
  • 04.30.12 2 years after the BP disaster began, the Gulf still needs your help. Watch & add your voice: http://t.co/RXmqXkTS @HealthyGulf
  • 04.26.12 Help end sex trafficking online. Sign petition telling @villagevoice to stop advertising girls for sex. http://t.co/g4DPzGd7 #dontsellgirls
  • 04.12.12 Tony Clifton is back!!! http://t.co/6HQ7uilM & http://t.co/vlsa0l6g
  • 03.31.12 Mike Mills on Dave FM from 8am to Noon today... radio takoever (repeat) http://t.co/UVlMYDBX
  • 03.29.12 Listen March 31st from 8am to 12Noon ET as dave-fm re-broadcasts the “Mike Mills Radio Takeover” http://t.co/UVlMYDBX
  • 03.23.12 Help support our veterans. Donate to get exclusive 10 track album featuring R.E.M. and 9 other great Athens bands http://t.co/2h4AftKp
  • 03.23.12 Bid on Michael's one-of-a-kind hand created book to benefit the Lunchbox Fund http://t.co/n903mR6u