For Collectors Only

The Five Satins Sing Their Greatest Hits may not have the fanciest packaging, and the sound is merely adequate, but it remains a hell of a good Five Satins collection, containing a robust 24 tracks. That means it doesn’t just have “In the Still of the Night,” it has a wealth of other singles that prove that the group was one of the finest doo wop outfits. Perhaps it could have been presented with a little more care, but it’s still a terrific overview. – Stephen Thomas Erlewine