Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers

Rate It! Avg: 4.0 (281 ratings)
Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 12   Total Length: 45:00

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
J. Edward Keyes

Editor-in-Chief

J. Edward Keyes has been writing about music for nearly 15 years, a fact he occasionally finds terrifying. His work has appeared in Rolling Stone, the Village V...more »

03.01.10
Making measured, deliberate music profoundly compelling
2003 | Label: Brassland

One of the most alluring aspects of Steinbeck's heartland novels is the brutal humanity of the characters. Desperate times create desperate people, and the final tragedy is as much a product of original sin as it is unfortunate circumstance. Brooklyn's the National understand this crippling frailty, and on their second record the band deftly sets the grim Calvinism of Nick Cave against rolling, expansive prairie music. The men on Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers are all bastards: quiet, bitter, swollen-headed drunks who hole up red-eyed in dark bedrooms, reeking of sweat and spent cigarettes. The protagonist of "Slipping Husband" is "haunted by the important life [he] could've led," and spends four verses skulking around the house and making his wife regret his decisions. "You own me," the lover on the last song admits, but then quickly appends the sentiment with a knowing "Lucky you." Matt Berninger's rueful gravel-bucket voice lets him shrug off heady lines like "Let her treat you like a criminal/ So you can treat her like a priest" without sounding haughty, and the record's earthy production lends the songs a warmth that serves to counteract the iciness of their subject matter. Like the Tindersticks and… read more »

Write a Review 2 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Great introduction to the National

DirkS.

I know Boxer and Alligator get all the hype, but this one has some great songs on it. "Slipping Husband" is one of my favorite National songs-- I love the lyrics of that one. Other highlights are, "Fashion Coat", "90 Mile Water Wall" and "Murder Me Rachel". If you like the National, this one is a must have.

user avatar

one man's opinion

rtabish

i sometimes wonder where reviewers get their references. while i can see the comparison of The National's song writing and vocal usage with Ray Davies, i can also hear a tinge of Warren Zevon and Tom Waits. i can draw comparisons between this band, especially on "murder me Rachel" with the electricity in some Grant Lee Buffalo or The Church. while i have never been much of a fan of introspective, nasally songs, it helps that there is a sensibility in songs like "trophy wife" that paint a bigger picture for the listener. this is great "sitting on the porch on a rainy afternoon" music. contemplative without being too emotional.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

eMusic Yearbook: 2005

By Chuck Eddy, eMusic Contributor

Indie-rock in the '00s was hardly the same animal as indie-rock two decades before, and much of the blame should probably go to Nirvana. In the '80s, labels like SST and Touch & Go were built on testosterone. But when grunge went multiplatinum in the '90s, rock bands brandishing palpable physicality suddenly qualified as mainstream again, and the bigger indies started adopting a more effete and introverted aesthetic. So if you skim down a list… more »

0

The Politic Melodic: A Campaign Song History

By Yancey Strickler, eMusic Contributor

In ways that grow more important by the day, the 1972 presidential contest between incumbent Republican Richard Nixon and Democrat George McGovern has dictated the tone, style and execution of every election since. It birthed the modern-day primary format; it defined and honed the press 'approach to all political coverage; it featured the most effective use of the presidency itself as a campaign asset; and, finally, even in defeat, McGovern's campaign dramatically shifted every campaign's… more »

They Say All Music Guide

For a band that’s been compared to Joy Division, Leonard Cohen, Wilco, and Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds, the National sure sounds a lot more like the Czars or Uncle Tupelo on this sophomore album Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers. Where the band might lack Joy Division’s angular fury, Cohen’s existentialism, and Cave’s vampiric attack, vocalist Matt Berninger and company whip up a murky alt country meets chamber pop vibe that’s quite potent. The five-piece mostly keeps things on the country side of the fence during the album’s first half, as slide guitars and fiddles overpower just about any hint of rock styling except the drumbeat, occasional feedback, and some screeching guitar freak-outs. Toward the album’s close, the songs’ textures finally shift from country to indie rock. Berninger is more than content to roam pastures featuring small patches of emo, sadcore, and artsy strings, clearly wearing his influences on his sleeve. Indeed, album-opener “Cardinal Song” could very easily be mistaken for the Tindersticks or Cousteau, with a passage that is a virtual note for note reconstruction of a Red House Painters song. Though the band focuses on slow atmospheric songs, it’s when it kicks out the jams that the music is the most compelling. Case in point is “Slipping Husband,” with its fine melodic waves and a perfectly placed bout of screaming. “Trophy Wife” presents yet another influence; the song seems a dead ringer for the Shins. It’s hard to shake the feeling that the National is highly influenced by and studied in the bands it emulates, but the album is still worth a listen for fans of moody country-tinged lounge music. With so many influences rearing their heads and ample musical chops in the bag, the National might not be masters of any one genre, but it creates a fine amalgam nonetheless. – Tim DiGravina

more »

Activity

  • 05.25.12 Check Out The National's version of "The Rains of Castamere" for Game of Thrones: http://t.co/LDp6Y6B5
  • 05.23.12 At Red Bull Stadium with @localnatives for @NewYorkRedBulls vs Chivas!! http://t.co/CKra1SSx
  • 05.23.12 Check it out kids: http://t.co/lSEkoTDB - Illustration: the amazing http://t.co/WX0nrOWP Narration: Matt, Music: Aaron & Bryce
  • 05.18.12 More bands have been added to ATP @localnatives @therealkurtvile and more! http://t.co/0kUWzRG3
  • 05.15.12 Check out a video from Crossing Brooklyn Ferry of Bryce, Aaron and @st_vincent on @pitchforkmedia +1 http://t.co/msS1yRg5
  • 05.15.12 RT: @lprnyc: Tonight - Man Forever (members of Oneida, @TheRealYLT, @The_National, @YYYs + more) w/ @Massdist & Nymph http://t.co/RSGRdoI5
  • 05.09.12 RT: @Brassland: 15%off sale on @The_National music all wk @ http://t.co/7MEeOeAp (CD/LP) + http://t.co/IPqaZWPU (MP3s) code "oneweekoneband"
  • 05.07.12 New poster sets, available now in our Shop: http://t.co/Z91PlasJ
  • 05.06.12 Phi Slamma Jamma playing Ramones with Arcade Fire :) BAM cafe
  • 05.06.12 They're might be a surprise performance in the BAM cafe later tonight :)
  • 05.03.12 Performances will start at 5pm at Crossing Brooklyn Ferry!
  • 05.03.12 Get High Violet, Boxer, and Alligator on @iTunesMusic for $7.99 this week: http://t.co/QkfZBLUF