Stiff Lovers Holymen Thieves

Rate It! Avg: 4.5 (28 ratings)
Stiff Lovers Holymen Thieves album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 11   Total Length: 59:30

eMusic Review 0

Avatar Image
Chris Nickson

eMusic Contributor

04.22.11
Longtime Waterson:Carthy sideman goes it alone.
2006 | Label: Topic / IODA

The solo debut from Tim Van Eyken makes you wonder why he was content to be a sideman for so long. He sets his stall out early by taking on "Barleycorn," a song already covered by too many people, and bringing an illuminating freshness to it, based around an electric guitar figure and his own slightly fragile, but appealing voice. While plenty of the material hews close to the tried-and-true, especially on the instrumentals, he's happy to take chances at times — "Fair Ellen of Ratcliffe" works as he adds touches of dub and folk rock as atmospheric ornamentation to an intense song, but "Babes in the Wood" and "Twelve Joys of Mary" end up trying too hard to be different and "interesting." That aside, Van Eyken has made a stunning start, and a successful leap from sideman to artist.

Write a Review 3 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

Fresh Air!

gussygoose

Good on Tim Van Eyken for taking on a song so well-known and so "over-covered" as (John) Barleycorn....and what a delight it is to hear him do it. It's as if he's singing the song for the very first time, and I'm hearing it for the first time! And all the other tracks are equally "fresh". Now that's talent.

user avatar

Gold

SirJohn

The whole album's a jewel. That said (and not to belittle Van Eyken's renderings of any other tune), this album's got the very best vesion of John Barleycorn that I've had the pleasure of cocking an ear to.

user avatar

A refreshing sound, magnificent voice and songs

ijkidd

My first download (and therefore review!) on emusic, I was delighted to see that this album was available as I have been looking forward to getting it for ages, so whilst on a tight budget it was a pleasure to get it with some of my free downloads. I had enjoyed his voice live playing with Waterson:Carthy but was never sure how well it would carry over a whole album, but then I didn't suspect how well he would be able to interpret these songs and make them sound so fresh and modern. My girlfriend literally had goosebumps and lumps in the throat listening to it. I can take or leave the jigs and reels (if that is what they are), but it is tracks like "Barleycorn", "Australia" and "Gypsy Maid" that make it a contemporary great in Folk for me.

Recommended Albums

eMusic Features

0

Young Guns of Britfolk

By Chris Nickson, eMusic Contributor

Through much of the 1980s, British folk was in a fairly moribund state. There were a few high spots, but it looked as if the spirit of the revival was slowly sputtering to nothing. In the 1990s, though, something unexpected happened. A new generation of folk musicians began to emerge. Some, like Eliza Carthy or Nancy Kerr, were the children of folk musicians and had been involved with the music all their lives. Others had… more »

They Say All Music Guide

Stepping out from his usual sideman role, Tim Van Eyken shows himself to be an excellent frontman on this solo disc. There’s a lot of confidence here, evidenced by kicking off with “Barleycorn,” a version of one of the best-known songs given a fresh, original, and quite catchy arrangement before heading out from there. As he’d proved before, he’s a very tidy box player, and he uses stalwart backing here, although perhaps the biggest revelation is his singing. It’s not obtrusive, but certainly quite persuasive, especially on “Fair Ellen of Ratcliffe,” an epic and gruesome tale that stands as the disc’s centerpiece before haring off into some modern and quite effective folk-rock. Good as this album is overall, not everything works. “Babes in the Wood” suffers from an arrangement that’s too cute by far, but also amorphous, while “Twelve Joys of Mary” seems to lack any focus or seriousness, a kind of English oompah. Cast those two aside and Van Eyken has made an impressive move ahead on a solo career. – Chris Nickson

more »