"The Music Box [JohnMetzger] #9"

"Amazon.com #5, Billboard #9"

"Cokemachineglow #10"

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #1, Austin C..." more

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #1, Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #1, Tiny Mix Tapes #6" less

"Boston Globe [JoanAnderman] #6, Rolli..." more

"Boston Globe [JoanAnderman] #6, Rolling Stone #8, New York Magazine #9" less

"Austin Chronical (Austin Powell) #7"

"Cokemachineglow #2"

"Sputnikmusic #4"

"eMusic [members] #1, Hartford Courant..." more

"eMusic [members] #1, Hartford Courant #1, Observer Music Monthly #1, Lost at Sea #2, Boston Globe [JohnAnderman] #2, The Guardian #2, Metacritic [userspoll] #2, Billboard #3, MusicOMH #3, New York Magazine #3, NoRipCord #3, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #4, Paste Magazine #4, Mojo #4, Uncut #4, Variety #4, A/V Club #5, Sputnikmusic #6, Filter #6, Metacritic [TopRated] #6, eMusic [editors] #6, EW [LeahGreenblatt] #8, Threadtrend #9" less

"Sputnikmusic #10"

"Now Toronto [BenjaminBoles] #6"

"Slate [RobertChristgau] #5"

"Drowned in Sound #3, Pitchfork #4, Th..." more

"Drowned in Sound #3, Pitchfork #4, Threadtrend #4, Popmatters #6, Tiny Mix Tapes #7, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #8, Filter #9, Lost at Sea #9" less

"Sputnikmusic #1"

"eMusic [editors] #2"

"Tiny Mix Tapes #1, Threadtrend #1, Au..." more

"Tiny Mix Tapes #1, Threadtrend #1, Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #3, The Phoenix #4, Metacritic [userspoll] #4, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #5, Drowned in Sound #5, Lost at Sea #5, Pitchfork #5, eMusic [members] #6, NoRipCord #6, Delusions of Adequacy #7, Popmatters #7, Spin #7, New York Times [JohnPareles] #8, Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #8, Paste Magazine #10" less

"New York Times [JohnPareles] #5, Lost..." more

"New York Times [JohnPareles] #5, Lost at Sea #10" less

"Filter #3"

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #3"

"The Wire #7"

"MusicOMH #10"

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #5"

"Billboard #1, Delusions of Adequacy #..." more

"Billboard #1, Delusions of Adequacy #1, Mojo #1, NoRipCord #1, Pitchfork #1, Under the Radar #1, Variety #1, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #2, Filter #2, Popmatters #2, Q #2, Uncut #2, Amazon.com #3, Threadtrend #3, Metacritic [userspoll] #3, MusicOMH #4, Tiny Mix Tapes #4, Spin #5, Paste Magazine #6, The Guardian #6, New York Magazine #7, Metacritic [TopRated] #7" less

"Slate [RobertChristgau] #1"

"Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #5"

"Drowned in Sound #8, NME #10"

"Drowned in Sound #2, eMusic [members]..." more

"Drowned in Sound #2, eMusic [members] #5, Magnet #7, eMusic [editors] #9, Chromewaves #9, Metacritic [userspoll] #9" less

"A/V Club #2, Now Toronto [BenjaminBol..." more

"A/V Club #2, Now Toronto [BenjaminBoles] # 2, Spin #4, Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #9" less

"Cokemachineglow #3, The Wire #5, Almo..." more

"Cokemachineglow #3, The Wire #5, Almost Cool #6, Tiny Mix Tapes #9" less

"Blender #2, Paste Magazine #7, Boston..." more

"Blender #2, Paste Magazine #7, Boston Globe [JoanAnderman] #9" less

"The Phoenix #7"

"Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #9"

"Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #7"

"Cokemachineglow #5"

"Almost Cool #7"

"Rolling Stone #5, The Music Box [John..." more

"Rolling Stone #5, The Music Box [JohnMetzger] #6, Variety #7" less

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #6"

"Slate [RobertChristgau] #7"

"A/V Club #4, Popmatters #10"

"Now Toronto [BenjaminBoles] #8"

"Dusted #6"

"Hartford Courant #8, Magnet #8"

"Now Toronto [BenjaminBoles] #6"

"Tiny Mix Tapes #10"

"Tiny Mix Tapes #5"

"Rolling Stone #4, eMusic [members] #7..." more

"Rolling Stone #4, eMusic [members] #7, Boston Globe [JoanAnderman] #10" less

"Almost Cool #2"

"Blender #7"

"eMusic [members] #3, Paste Magazine #..." more

"eMusic [members] #3, Paste Magazine #5, Chromewaves #6, Delusions of Adequacy #9" less

"The Quietus #9"

"Cokemachineglow #8"

"The Wire #2"

"Almost Cool #10"

"Metacritic [TopRated] #3"

"Sputnikmusic #9"

"eMusic [members] #10"

"The Music Box [JohnMetzger] #1"

"eMusic [editors] #3, Boston Globe [Ja..." more

"eMusic [editors] #3, Boston Globe [JamesReed] #9" less

"Amazon.com #2, Billboard #2, Boston G..." more

"Amazon.com #2, Billboard #2,
Boston Globe [JamesReed] #2, Hartford Courant #2, EW [LeahGreenblatt] #3, Rollingstone #6, Spin #6, Slant Magazine #9, eMusic [members] #9, New York Times [JohnPareles] #10, Los Angeles Times (top 10)" less

"Boston Globe [SarahRodman] #1, Paste ..." more

"Boston Globe [SarahRodman] #1, Paste Magazine #1, Threadtrend #6, Under the Radar #6, Filter #7" less

"Chromewaves #3, NoRipCord #7"

"Paste Magazine #2, Chromewaves #2, Va..." more

"Paste Magazine #2, Chromewaves #2, Variety #3, Lost at Sea #8, EW [LeahGreenblatt] #10" less

"Magnet #6, Now Toronto [MichaelHollet..." more

"Magnet #6, Now Toronto [MichaelHollett]#8" less

"Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #6, N..." more

"Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #6, NoRipCord #10" less

"Delusions of Adequacy #10"

"eMusic [editors] #7"

"The Wire #6"

"The Wire #1, The Quietus #1, Metacrit..." more

"The Wire #1, The Quietus #1, Metacritic [TopRated] #2, Popmatters #5, Mojo #9" less

"Almost Cool #1, Under the Radar #3, M..." more

"Almost Cool #1, Under the Radar #3, Metacritic [userspoll] #7, Magnet #10" less

"eMusic [editors] #1"

"EW [ChrisWillman] #1, Hartford Couran..." more

"EW [ChrisWillman] #1, Hartford Courant #3, eMusic [members] #4, Delusions of Adequacy #5, Mojo #6, A/V Club #6, Boston Globe [SarahRodman] #7, NoRipCord #8" less

"Drowned in Sound #9"

"Mojo #2"

"Almost Cool #9"

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #7, The Phoe..." more

"Boston Globe [JamesReed] #7, The Phoenix #8" less

"Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #2, A..." more

"Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #2, A/V Club #3, Cokemachineglow #7, eMusic [editors] #8, eMusic [members] #8, Metacritic [userspoll] #8" less

"Mojo #8"

"Magnet #5"

"Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #6"

"Tiny Mix Tapes #8"

"A/V Club #1, Rolling Stone #1, Pitchf..." more

"A/V Club #1, Rolling Stone #1, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #1, New York Times [JohnPareles] #1, Spin #1, EW [LeahGreenblatt] #1, The Guardian #1, Metacritic [userspoll] #1, MusicOMH #2, NME #2, New York Magazine #2, Variety #2, Blender #3, Delusions of Adequacy #3, Popmatters #3, Sputnikmusic #3, Tiny Mix Tapes #3, Uncut #3, Slant Magazine #4, Boston
Globe [JoanAnderman] #4, Filter #4, Lost at Sea #4, Slate [RobertChristgau] #4, Austin Chronicle [AustinPowell] #4, Metacritic [TopRated] #4, NoRipCord #5, Pitchfork #6, Billboard #6, Q #7, Magnet #9, Boston Globe [SarahRodman] #10, EW [ChrisWillman] #10, Observer Music Monthly #10, Los Angeles Times (top 10)" less

"eMusic [members] #2, Under the Radar ..." more

"eMusic [members] #2, Under the Radar #2, Pitchfork [ReadersPoll] #3, Paste Magazine #3, Billboard #4, NME #4, Q #4, Boston Globe [SarahRodman] #5, Uncut #5, Variety #5, MusicOMH #6, Metacritic [userspoll] #6, Observer Music Monthly #7, A/V Club #7, Pitchfork #7, The Guardian #7, Boston Globe [JoanAnderman] #8, Delusions of Adequacy #8, NoRipCord #9, Blender #9, Rolling Stone #10, Boston Globe [JamesReed] #10, New York Magazine #10" less

"eMusic [editors] #4"

"eMusic [editors] #5"

"Cokemachineglow #9"

"Lost at Sea #1, Drowned in Sound #7, ..." more

"Lost at Sea #1, Drowned in Sound #7, Slant Magazine #10" less

"The Quietus #6"

"Variety #9"

"Cokemachineglow #4, Austin Chronicle ..." more

"Cokemachineglow #4, Austin Chronicle [AudraSchroeder] #10" less