 |
INTERVIEW WITH ROBERT HUGILL Randy: Robert, first, I want to welcome you and let everyone know that they can get your composition, Passion, on the album Passion performed by The Burgundian Cadence (a vocal quartet of bass, two tenors and a counter-tenor.) Looks from my web research that you were born in 1955 in North Lincolnshire, England, pursued the study of mathematics at the University of Manchester as well as choral singing and directing and now divide your time between computer programming and composition. You did some composing in the 1980s and focused more and more on composing at time went by -- writing a musical and then having a serious classical piece, 'Three Prayers', performed by the London Concord Singers in 1993. After that it looked like you wrote additional "serious music" including a one-act opera of about an hour's length called "Garrett". I get the idea that you concentrated on composing around the age of 30 or so -- this is traditionally a late age to get started -- what encouraged you to become a composer and how do you view your body of work so far? Robert: I wrote quite a lot of music when I was in my teens, but doing a degree in Mathematics meant that I did not really continue with this. For the first 5 years of my working life, I lived in Scotland and acted as the musical director of my local church. This meant that I ended up arranging pieces for the choir and I experimented with writing one or two for them. Once I had moved to London, I became the musical director for the Pink Singers in 1983. The choir had formed that year and were London's first Lesbian and Gay choir. After 3 months their original musical director left and I took over as a stopgap because my then partner was in the choir. I ended up staying for 5 years, arranging a large amount of music for the choir, mainly American popular songs and through the choir came into contact with a number of professional cabaret performers. I wrote and arranged music for these groups and even acted as artistic advisor for one group. This phase culminated in my musical 'Choices' and its follow up, the musical review 'The Pleasure of your Company'. But things move on, and gradually my cabaret contacts ceased working in the business or returned home to America and Australia. I continued writing music for choral groups, inspired by my own choral singing. By this time I was singing in London Concord Singers and doing a weekly sung Latin mass (complete with Gregorian chant and polyphonic mass settings) at St. Mary's Roman Catholic Church, Cadogan Street, Chelsea. I persuaded a group of friends (bribing them with the promise of food) to come to my house and sing some of my pieces. The results were surprisingly successful and I repeated these "sing-throughs" until we eventually gave a concert in 1994. This was the origin of my own choir, FifteenB. I think that the catalyst for this change to more serious music was my extensive exposure to singing Gregorian chant at St. Mary's church, though I cannot explain why. My work so far falls into two distinct categories the cabaret and the serious; though a cabaret song such as 'Microprocessor Man' proved complex enough for the SPNM to select it for performance by the Ensemble Aleph at the Bath Festival. And the song cycle, 'Songs of Love and Loss', which deals with death and bereavement, actually incorporates a piece which started out as a cabaret song (admittedly a rather gloomy one). I tend to use songs for experiment, whereas my political and didactic instincts often come out in my large scale choral pieces and I find that writing short unaccompanied choral motets (usually in Latin) a means of relaxation. Randy: There seems to be a lot of Medieval and Gregorian chant influences in your music as well as Renaissance and Baroque and even more modern influences. Also, it seems you are continuing the great tradition of English choral music composers - how do you view your influences and your approach to composition? Robert: My biggest influence during my cabaret period was probably the music of Kurt Weill and Hanns Eisler. I admire not only Weill's music, but how, in his American period, he insisted on keeping control of the process of writing his musicals by doing all of his own orchestrations. I have a great knowledge and love of the music of Vaughan Williams dating back to my days in a youth orchestra in 1972 playing excerpts of his "Job". I never consciously try to include references to a composer into a piece. In fact I am rather bad at pastiche and if I try to write in a particular style then things normally go off in a tangential direction. Sometimes influences can appear in unlikely places, a friend once informed me that a French café waltz from my musical reminded him strongly of a hymn by John Ireland. For me, composing is rather like an archaeologist excavating a statue. You have some inkling of a piece's ultimate shape and form but the composing process is akin to trying to uncover something that already exists and is only waiting to be revealed. Sometimes, this process is a bit 'hit and miss' and pieces can go through variants until they feel 'right'. I am a very word oriented composer. Much of my music is either word setting or has words lying behind it. I am influenced by the sound of words, so that my settings of Latin texts inevitably bring along echoes of Gregorian chant. Some of my sacred pieces have been based on chant or have consciously emulated it, but in others the chant has simply worked its way in unbeknownst to me. And in my opera 'Garrett' I was surprised to find that the singers thought that my recitative was heavily plainchant influenced. Randy: Classical music has pretty much departed from an extended period of great dissonance and a near obsession with atonality to now find itself in territory more closely aligned with the tradition of art music prior to the twentieth century. Now with the "post-modern" period, more composers are embracing a much friendlier and, I suppose in the mind of the general audience, a more agreeable music -- so much of it tonal or modal. I realize to some extent, many English composers like Vaughan Williams, Walton, Britten and John Taverner kept their music relatively accessible when other composers on the continent and particularly in America were chasing patrons away from the concert halls. How do you see yourself fitting into the tradition of English choral music and how do you see your place in a post-modern classical world? Where do you think classical or serious music is headed now? Robert: I would imagine that my music fits into the English choral tradition. It has produced music that I love -- and as a singer I am part of the same performing tradition. But I never set out to produce a work that fits into this tradition. I have never consciously aligned myself with any particular grouping of composers, but I find it difficult writing a line of music that I can't sing. So this does rather fix my place in the world. I have written a lot of music to be sung by singers (both choirs and soloists) in the voluntary sector (people who used to be called amateurs). When writing such pieces, I am concerned about issues such as the difficulty of the line and how interesting it is to sing. Such concerns may lead me to make changes to a piece, but I must admit that there are times when I ignore such concerns and concentrate on the sheer shape of a piece, perhaps at the expense of its singability or interest to singers. It is perfectly possible to write a great piece of music that is unsingable and I have great admiration for composers who are constantly challenging the boundaries of what is possible, but I am not one of these. It is also possible to write a fine piece of music that is more than the sum of its parts and is essentially boring for the individual singers. I try not to do this, as when working with amateurs you get a better performance if their imagination is engaged. Regarding the future of music, composers have to go back to having more feeling for the impact that the work will have on their audience. The notion of composer as artist, almost independent of the concert hall, in conjunction with a system of grants and commissions which can insulate a composer, artistically and economically, from the effect that their work might have on an audience has led to some rather selfish performances by composers. I am not saying that we all need to write works that are crowd pullers, but simply that a composer should take account of the economic effects of his work. Helpfully, this selfishness is being countered by the increasing tendency for composers to turn performer or impresario. In part this is through sheer necessity, as the current economic climate has ceased to support the classical composer artist in the way that it did in the 50's, 60's and 70's. This means that an increasing numbers of composers are forced to balance artistic integrity with economic necessity - which can only be a good thing. Randy: I don't hear a trace of rock music in Passion. In contrast to most of rock it is very relaxing, peaceful music -- but you must have been exposed to a substantial amount of rock including the English progressive rock of the seventies. What kind of music did you like growing up and has rock had any influence in your music? Robert: I was exposed to and listened to a fair amount of rock music in the 70's when I was a student. I bought Pink Floyd albums and had a liking for ELP (Emerson Lake and Palmer) and the heavier brand of rock. But at the same time, I was performing Bach, Beethoven, Handel, etc. in University choirs and orchestras. Ultimately, it is the music that I have performed, and been a part of, that has influenced me most. Rock music, just listened to on disc, never completely penetrated my consciousness. As I started performing the popular standards of American popular music (Cole Porter, Irving Berlin, Gershwin, etc.), these did penetrate and had an important effect on my early music. The other area of popular music that has had some effect is disco music. This is the music that I danced to in the 80's and I have written one or two pieces which are disco influenced, notably my 'Requiem for a Dancing Homosexual' a requiem mass based on themes from songs such as 'Its Raining Men' (The Weather Girls) and 'Smalltown Boy' (Bronski Beat - in fact the Pink Singers were the backing group for two numbers on Bronski Beat's first album). Randy: Although Passion is well written for the voice (four voices in this case) -- it doesn't seem to be the kind of music that is easy to perform -- being a cappella is always tough and then you throw into that mix a challenging counter-tenor part, polyphonic writing and several instances of chromaticism and diatonic divergences (going away from a traditional key structure) that must have required both talented singers and significant practice. Please tell us a little about the rehearsals and the recording of this work. Robert: Passion was written for a particular group of people and in particular circumstances. Counter-tenor Rupert Damerell sang with a 4-man ensemble, 'The Burgundian Cadence' who specialized in music by such composers as Dunstable, Binchois, Dufay and Machaut. All the music was sung unaccompanied and their concerts mixed motets with early plainchant. Rupert, who had both sung for me and recorded concerts of my music, broached the possibility of my writing a piece for the group. It had to fit into their existing repertoire. I had been toying with the idea of a passion and these ideas all came together when Rupert suggested that the recitative could be sung as chant with a discreet accompaniment (the group had already been experimenting with adding drones to their plainchant). One of the aims of the groups was to sing their chosen repertoire in suitable tunings (singing pieces in a key comfortable for the singers); so my piece, tricky though it is, was something that fell well within the bounds of possibility. From the very first performance (I was not present at rehearsals and simply answered Rupert's queries by email), the piece was sung with an uncanny accuracy and I had even been offered a choice of tunings for the piece. I was not present at the recording as this took place after a seven-venue tour that provided time for the work to settle down. Randy: This is both a wonderful work of music and a wonderful religious work (here is a link to the text at the publishers website) -- is there anything you would like to add about the program of the work that is not self evident from the text? Also how did you apply your compositional technique to support the text? Robert: I would hope that the text of Passion is reasonably self-evident. In editing it, I was concerned to emphasize the more dramatic aspects of the text rather than creating a strictly religious work. To this end, I included the poems by Carl Cook. These are not strictly religious at all but Carl mixes religious and sexual imagery in his work in a way that appeals to me. Quite early on, I decided I wanted to include interludes in the works, analogous to the arias in the Bach oratorios, and that these interludes should form some sort of contemporary commentary rather than being strictly devotional. Another aspect of the work, which was present from the first, was the idea to present Christ as a counter-tenor. I surrounded all of Christ's utterances with a slow moving halo of humming from the other singers; this combined with the timbre of Rupert's voice were intended to achieve a sort of otherworldly, spaced-out feeling to Christ's music. Regarding my compositional technique, it is rather harder to comment. I deliberately tried to use a plainchant-like feel for the setting of the Biblical text, but was concerned to vary the pacing and texture. This was partly because I was confident that the group's experience with real plainchant would mean that they could interpret the piece as I intended and bring out the nuances of the text; it is important to me that the text was comprehensible at all times. The settings of Carl's poems were intended to deliberately break the mood. Whereas the Biblical text is set for one voice either accompanied or unaccompanied, the poems treat the four voices equally. Randy: Robert, thanks for your participation and congratulations on writing such an enjoyable work as Passion. I am definitely looking forward to more music from you here at eMusic. Best wishes in your pursuits as a composer!
|